Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2025 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2025R7 · #239
RB· Round 7

Phil
Mafah.

Phil Mafah
Sickos Grade
36.5/100

Clemson official athletic logoClemson· 6'1"· 234 lb

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9237
National · #188HS class · 2021
Grayson, GA
247Sports composite via CFBD
R7 · #239 · DAL

"Mafah is the rare modern back who still wins by wearing a defense down, a 234-pound downhill hammer whose fourth-quarter carries look exactly like his first-quarter carries."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Mafah is a true downhill A-gap runner who spent four years as Clemson's short-yardage and closing back before finally owning the job as a senior. He presses the line with square pads, works off the guard's hip, and finishes forward on nearly every rep; the tackle-breaking comes from mass, leg drive and a surprisingly loose spin move rather than shake.

The secondary trait is durability of tempo: he carried 216 times in 2024 and the fourth quarter looked like the first, with 1,115 yards and eight scores. He is a straight-line athlete, not a creator, so the ceiling is tied to blocking, but the signature is the goal-line and third-and-short conversion where he simply refuses to be stopped short.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Gap/power run game with a defined short-yardage and goal-line package

I-formation tailbackShotgun single backGoal-line leadShort-yardage closer
Best role

Year 1: third running back and core special-teamer who owns the goal-line and third-and-one package. Ceiling: 120-carry complement in a two-man committee that hands him every early-down and red-zone rep.

Wrong fit

A wide-zone, one-back offense that asks its lone back to play all three downs, split out in empty and win one-on-one in protection — Mafah would be off the field on every obvious passing down.

Value rises sharply on a team with a shifty change-of-pace starter that needs a hammer for the last yard.

03Film room

Phil Mafah Mid-Season Highlights | 2024 ACC Football

Senior-year cutup showing the downhill pad level and short-yardage finishing that defined his 1,115-yard season.

Clemson RB Phil Mafah vs Georgia | Every Play

Full-game reps against an NFL front — the cleanest look at what he can and cannot create when the blocking fails.

Phil Mafah Runs For Over 150 Yards Against FSU

Volume game where the contact balance and late-game tempo show up drive after drive.

04The evaluation

Mafah profiles as a classic big-bodied inside runner, 6-1 and 234 pounds, with a body type and running style that has been squeezed out of the modern draft's first two days. He is a one-speed, one-plan back, and the plan works: get downhill, stay square, fall forward.

The production tells the story of patience. He was the closer behind Will Shipley for three years, scoring 13 touchdowns as a junior on 179 carries, then broke 1,000 yards as a senior with 1,115 on 216 attempts. The flags were equally clear: 57 career receptions in four seasons, negligible juice in space, and a limited pass-protection sample that asked NFL staffs to project rather than confirm.

Boards had him in the fifth-to-sixth range as a two-down complement, and the slide to 239 reflected how little the league pays for backs without third-down value. Dallas took the swing knowing exactly what it was buying: a short-yardage insurance policy and a special-teams body, at the price where that bet costs nothing.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Short-yardage finisher

    Squares up, keeps his pads under the linebacker's chest and converts the one-yard play at a rate that shows up on every Clemson goal-line cutup.

  2. 02

    Contact balance

    Absorbs the first hit through the hip and stays upright, turning what should be two-yard runs into four-yard runs against loaded fronts.

  3. 03

    Volume durability

    Handled 216 carries as a senior and 561 for his career without missing meaningful time, and his late-game reps carry the same pad level as his early ones.

  4. 04

    Vision on gap schemes

    Reads the down block and pulling guard cleanly, pressing the hole before cutting so the puller can wall off the second-level defender.

  5. 05

    Surprising spin

    Uses a compact, well-timed spin out of contact that resets his path without losing forward momentum, unusual for a back his size.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    No third-down role

    57 catches in four seasons on a limited route tree, and he is not a natural hands-catcher outside checkdowns to the flat.

  2. 02

    Straight-line athlete

    Lacks the lateral burst to make the first unblocked defender miss, so negative plays stay negative when the front wins.

  3. 03

    Pass protection projection

    Willing and strong at the point but late to identify pressure, and the blitz-pickup sample at Clemson was thin.

  4. 04

    Long-speed ceiling

    Rarely finishes explosive runs; his longest gains come from broken tackles rather than pulling away from the safety angle.

08College production
YrTeamGAttYdsTDRecRecYds
2021Clemson9682923638
2022Clemson14985154948
2023Clemson131799651321108
2024Clemson142161115821103
Career5056128872857297

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Efficiency, 2024
average
Predicted Points Added / play
+0.105
percentile at position
45%
PPA · pass
-0.187
PPA · rush
+0.140
CFBD PPA — 0 = league-average play
/ Usage share, 2024
25.0%of team plays
93 percentile at positionClemson
Pass plays · 4.9%Run plays · 50.1%Third down · 17.2%Passing downs · 16.4%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
Share of production2024 · Clemson
4%of the offense's positive expected-points output
Production share4%
Snap share25%
  • Cade KlubnikQB29%
  • Antonio WilliamsWR15%
  • Bryant Wesco Jr.WR8%

#8 of 18 tracked contributors · Production leaned on volume · Offense explosiveness 1.25 (p41) · CFBD — usage x PPA per tracked player

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Zach ZennerDET

Roster-bubble power back who lives on special teams and short-yardage packages and appears when the depth chart thins.

/ Ceiling
Alexander MattisonMIN

Same downhill build and finishing style, with enough volume competence to start a stretch of games when the RB1 goes down.

/ Floor
Sean TuckerTB

Talented college producer whose lack of passing-down value keeps him inactive and off the touch distribution entirely.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
1
Career AV

Dallas kept Mafah through the summer and carried him as a depth back behind Javonte Williams and rookie Jaydon Blue, with the roster churn of a crowded room limiting him to one appearance in 2025. In that game he touched it seven times, five carries for 18 yards and a touchdown plus two catches for 11, which is a fair snapshot of the role the Cowboys drafted him for: an emergency short-yardage body who can be trusted to finish a goal-line rep. He returned to the roster for the 2026 offseason still competing for the third running back job.

In hindsight the pick is neither a miss nor a discovery yet. Seventh-round backs with no passing-down value survive on special teams and inside-run insurance, and Mafah has not been given the volume to prove or disprove the college tape. The honest read is that the trait that made him draftable, converting the one-yard play, is the hardest thing to showcase from the inactive list, and that his career will be decided by an injury in front of him rather than by anything he controls.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile