Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2025 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2025Consensus #027
S· Round 1

Malaki
Starks.

Malaki Starks
Sickos Grade
80.3/100
Pre-draft #27

Georgia official athletic logoGeorgia· 6'1"· 197 lb· 4.50s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★★stars.9905
National · #19HS class · 2022
Jefferson, GA
247Sports composite via CFBD
R1 · #27 · Baltimore Ravens

"A modern chess-piece safety who can play the deep middle, roll into the slot and take the tight end, in the mold of Jessie Bates III: instinct-first coverage range and pro-ready mental processing rather than a knockout hitter."Pre-draft read

01Play style

This free safety aligns across the deep half, single-high, in the slot, and in the box. His play is characterized by spatial processing, where he reads the quarterback's hips and route stems from depth. He triggers downhill without false steps and takes efficient angles across the field. Ball skills are a secondary trait; he attacks the catch point with timing rather than relying on length. His footwork in the backpedal is clean, and his pedal-to-drive transition is compact.

In run support, he is a wrap-and-drag tackler who arrives under control, rather than a strike-first hitter. He takes on blocks with leverage instead of power. He demonstrates the ability to be assignment-flipped mid-drive without a loss in play quality.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

This prospect thrives in a quarters or Cover-3 match system that leverages his spatial processing and versatility to cover ground laterally and vertically with equal facility.

Free safetySlot DBDeep halfDimebacker
Best role

Baltimore found their immediate plug-and-play single-high free safety, capable of growing into a chess piece that can align anywhere in the defensive backfield.

Wrong fit

He would be incredibly undervalued if asked to play as a pure strong safety who is routinely asked to take on blocks in the box or play significant man coverage.

His high-level spatial processing and tackling reliability make him a scheme-versatile defensive back capable of playing multiple roles from day one, assuming he is not asked to generate power directly.

03Film room

Malaki Starks Full College Football Highlights | Georgia Star Safety

Three-season cut showing the range from deep middle, the slot reps and the pedal-to-drive transition.

Georgia Safety Malaki Starks 2024 Highlights

The 2024 role closer to the line: run-fit angles, alley tackling and the four tackles for loss.

Malaki Starks UGA Safety Highlights 2022

True freshman tape from the national title season, including the ball production that defined his first two years.

04The evaluation

This player projects as a versatile, positionless safety with significant slot flexibility, making him a valuable asset for a team seeking a dependable back-end organizer. He offers reliable tackling, strong spatial awareness, and a proven ability to process and react to plays from various alignments. A team drafting him is acquiring a high-floor player who can contribute immediately in multiple defensive schemes.

A three-year starter, he was on the field from Week 1 as a true freshman on a national championship team, maintaining a streak of 43 consecutive starts. His early career featured significant ball production, with six interceptions and 14 pass breakups in 2022-23 as a deep-field player. His 2024 season saw a role change closer to the line, resulting in a career-high 77 tackles and four tackles for loss, but reduced ball hawking.

Evaluators consistently praised his three-phase versatility, tackling reliability, and character. However, concerns about his 2024 production dip and a body type that lacks true enforcer mass led to a range of opinions, from a top-12 lock to a late-first-round pick. He was ultimately drafted at pick 27, providing a plug-and-play free safety for a defense with an established strong safety.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Deep-middle range

    Covers hash to sideline from single-high with clean pedal-to-drive mechanics, closing on throws because his read starts before the ball leaves the hand.

  2. 02

    Positional versatility

    Logged meaningful snaps at deep half, post safety, nickel and dime linebacker, trusted to change alignment inside a drive without a coverage bust.

  3. 03

    Ball production

    Six career interceptions and 17 pass breakups, including a 42-yard pick as a true freshman; he attacks the catch point with timing.

  4. 04

    Reliable tackling

    197 career stops with a low miss rate; he arrives under control, wraps through the hip and drags ballcarriers down.

  5. 05

    Mental processing

    Handled checks, rotations and disguise duty as a three-year starter; Georgia's secondary communication ran through him.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Play strength

    At 197 pounds with 31 5/8-inch arms, he gets stalled by tight ends and pulling guards in the alley, and stacking blocks is a clear hole.

  2. 02

    2024 production dip

    One interception and three breakups in his final year, a function of a role change, but allowed doubters an argument near the top of the board.

  3. 03

    Long speed

    A 4.50 forty is functional rather than special; true burners can stack him vertically when he opens his hips a beat late.

  4. 04

    Man coverage on islands

    Lacks the short-area twitch to erase a starting slot receiver over a full series without safety help behind him.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'1"
Weight
197 lb
40 yd
4.50s
Vertical
33"
3-cone
7.26s
Shuttle
4.45s
06Athletic profilevs. S on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.50sp50
Vertical
33inp50
Broad jump
in
Three-cone
7.26sp50
Shuttle
4.45sp50
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGTklSkIntPDFF
2022Georgia15600270
2023Georgia14520370
2024Georgia14770130
Career4318906170

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

Honors

  • CFP National Champion (2022)
  • Consensus All-American (2023)
  • First-team All-American (2024)
  • Two-time first-team All-SEC (2023, 2024)
  • Freshman All-American (2022)
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Jeremy ChinnLas Vegas Raiders

A trusted multi-alignment starter who plays every snap, handles the communication and produces a steady but not spectacular takeaway line.

/ Ceiling
Jessie Bates IIIAtlanta Falcons

The realistic ceiling: a post safety whose anticipation turns into double-digit takeaways over a few seasons and lets a coordinator play any coverage shell.

/ Floor
Jaquan BriskerChicago Bears

A dependable starter whose value gets capped when he is asked to be the last line of defense against elite vertical speed.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
1
Career AV

Started 15 of 17 games as a rookie for the Ravens in 2025, taking over the free safety job in training camp and posting 84 tackles, two interceptions, one tackle for loss and four pass breakups.

The pre-draft argument over Malaki Starks was never about whether he could play. It was about what he was. Georgia handed him the starting free safety job in his first fall camp, on a defense that would win a national championship, and he never gave it back across 43 consecutive starts. Through 2022 and 2023 he looked like a takeaway machine in the making, with six interceptions and 14 breakups and the kind of range that lets a coordinator live in single-high without apologizing for it. Then 2024 pulled him closer to the line of scrimmage, and the box score changed shape: a career-high 77 tackles and four tackles for loss, but only one interception and three breakups on a Bulldogs defense whose defensive back havoc rate fell to 4.7 percent. Boards that valued splash saw a player sliding. Boards that watched the assignments saw a defense using its most reliable communicator to patch a leak. The truth sat with the second group, but the debate was real enough to move him from a projected top-12 pick to the back half of the first round.

Baltimore was a clean landing spot precisely because it did not need him to be a hitter. With an established strong safety already in place, Starks could play the role that made him valuable in Athens: the deep-field organizer who takes efficient angles, tackles securely in space and can be flipped into the slot on a tight end without a coordinator flinching. His rookie year confirmed the projection rather than exploded past it. Fifteen starts in 17 games, 84 tackles, two interceptions, four passes defensed. That is a starting NFL safety in year one, not a revelation, and it fits the honest evaluation. The remaining questions are the ones scouts flagged in March. He is a 197-pound safety who has to survive contact from tight ends in the alley, his 4.50 speed is functional rather than frightening against true vertical threats, and he has never been the player who jars the ball loose. The realistic path forward is a decade of clean, versatile, high-floor safety play, with the interception total climbing as he sees more of the same route concepts. That is what pick 27 is supposed to buy.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile