Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2025 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2025Consensus #065
DT· Round 3

Darius
Alexander.

Darius Alexander
Sickos Grade
63.2/100
Pre-draft #65

Toledo official athletic logoToledo· 6'4"· 305 lb· 4.95s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★☆☆stars.8006
National · #2508HS class · 2019
Wayne, IN
247Sports composite via CFBD
R3 · #65 · New York Giants

"A long-armed, plan-driven interior rusher who looked quicker against Power Four blockers in Mobile than he had all fall, Alexander's NFL value hinges on translating his disruptive flashes against MAC competition to a higher level of play."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Alexander is a three-down interior defender who lined up everywhere from 3-technique to head-up nose in Toledo's four-man front, and his game starts with length. He fires into first contact with a heavy punch, extends into a blocker's chest to keep his frame clean, and reads the play from an arm's distance. When his pad level stays low he anchors the point of attack and stacks combo blocks without surrendering his gap.

As a rusher he works with a plan: a slide-and-swim to force whiffs, a long-arm to collapse the pocket, and active hands to counter once the first move stalls. He is a builder rather than an exploder, winning late in the down more than off the snap, but the flashes of power through contact are the signature that travels.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Attacking one-gap four-man front that lets him slant as a 3-technique next to a true nose and rush the B gap on passing downs.

3-technique4i-techniqueHead-up nose (base)NASCAR interior rusher
Best role

Year 1: rotational 3-technique on 35-45% of snaps. Ceiling: every-down starting three-technique in an attacking even front.

Wrong fit

A two-gap 3-4 that asks him to read-and-react at 0/2i and hold double teams for a full 60-snap workload, where his rising pad level gets exposed.

His value comes from being sent, not from being asked to wait.

03Film room

Darius Alexander Highlights | Toledo DT | 2025 New York Giants Draft Pick

Career highlight reel from Toledo showing his long-arm bull rush and gap-holding work.

Darius Alexander College Football Highlights | Toledo Defensive Tackle | NFL Draft Film

Draft film cut-up of his 2024 senior season, including the six-overtime bowl pick-six.

Giants DT Darius Alexander Film Breakdown (Toledo)

Film breakdown of his hand usage, slide-and-swim counter and pad-level inconsistency.

04The evaluation

A sixth-year senior who arrived at Toledo as a raw 2019 recruit and left as the most disruptive interior player in the MAC, Alexander is a rare small-school big man whose traits outrun his production. Size, length and physicality let him project into either odd or even fronts, and evaluators liked that he was never a one-note nose or a one-note penetrator.

The production curve tells the story. He was a reserve for two years, broke through with seven tackles for loss in 2022, added 4.0 sacks and Third-team All-MAC honors in 2023, then closed with a Second-team All-MAC senior year of 40 tackles, 7.5 TFL, 3.5 sacks and a 58-yard pick-six in the six-overtime GameAbove Sports Bowl win over Pitt. The signature week was Mobile, where he looked quicker against Power Four blockers than he had all fall. The flags: level of competition, a pad level that rose in traffic, and an age that made him a 24-year-old rookie.

The board landed him in the middle of the second-round-to-early-third band, with Brugler calling his peak plays reminiscent of Leonard Williams and Zierlein warning he might only be rotational for now. New York spent its lone Day 2 pick on him for one reason: a three-technique with this length next to Dexter Lawrence is a plus bet even if the floor is rotational.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Length and extension

    34-inch arms let him lock out into a blocker's chest, keep his frame clean, and shed late without ever letting the block get into his body.

  2. 02

    Rush plan

    Sets up his moves rather than freelancing, pairing a slide-and-swim to force whiffs with a long-arm bull that walks guards back into the quarterback.

  3. 03

    Point-of-attack strength

    Wide base and heavy hands allow him to absorb combo blocks and double teams while holding his gap and still making the tackle.

  4. 04

    Scheme flexibility

    Enough mass to play head-up nose and enough get-off to slant as a 3-technique, so both odd and even fronts had him on the board.

  5. 05

    All-star week riser

    Looked quicker and more disruptive against Power Four blockers in Mobile than he had all fall, which answered the biggest MAC-level question.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Get-off

    A long strider who is not explosive out of his stance, so he wins late in the down instead of beating blockers to the spot.

  2. 02

    Pad level

    Rises out of his stance in traffic, which makes his gap constriction hit-or-miss and lets bigger guards get underneath his chest plate.

  3. 03

    Age and runway

    A 24-year-old rookie coming out of a sixth college season, so the development curve buyers were paying for is shorter than the tape suggests.

  4. 04

    Production volume

    Nine career sacks across five seasons of MAC snaps is modest for a player being drafted on disruption, and the pressure came in bursts.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'4"
Weight
305 lb
40 yd
4.95s
Vertical
31.5"
Broad
9'3"
3-cone
7.60s
Shuttle
4.79s
Bench
28
06Athletic profilevs. DT on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.95sp50
Vertical
31.5inp50
Broad jump
111inp50
Three-cone
7.60sp50
Shuttle
4.79sp50
Bench
28repp50
08College production
YrTeamGTklSkIntPDFF
2020Toledo690000
2021Toledo13200020
2022Toledo13191.5030
2023Toledo14363.5030
2024Toledo12403.5140
Career581248.51120

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Roy Robertson-HarrisNew York Giants

Long-armed rotational interior starter who produces useful pressure without carrying a full early-down workload.

/ Ceiling
Leonard WilliamsSeattle Seahawks

Long, scheme-versatile interior lineman who turns length and hand power into a decade of three-down starting snaps.

/ Floor
Khalil DavisTampa Bay Buccaneers (2020-21)

Traits-first interior body whose flashes never turn into a steady role before the athletic edge fades.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
0
Career AV

The Giants got exactly what the pick implied. Alexander opened his rookie year in the interior rotation next to Dexter Lawrence, took on a bigger workload as the season went, and finished 2025 with 16 games played, two starts, 20 tackles, four tackles for loss, six quarterback hits, 3.5 sacks and a pass defensed. The best day came at Detroit on November 23, when he posted career highs of four tackles, 2.0 sacks and two tackles for loss and became the first Giants rookie with 2.0 sacks in the first half of a game since Jason Pierre-Paul in 2010. He was never asked to be a full-time early-down anchor, and the snap counts reflected a team easing a small-school lineman into an NFL front.

One year in, the read is a hit on the process even if the ceiling is unresolved. Alexander's 3.5 sacks were the pressure production the third-round grade was betting on, and the run defense held up well enough that he was on the field in base looks by December. The old concerns did not disappear: the get-off is still average, the pad level still rises against power, and at 25 there is less projection left than there would be for a younger rookie. But as a complementary interior rusher next to a defense-defining nose, he is already doing the job he was drafted to do.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile