Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2024 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2024Consensus #066
RB· Round 3

Trey
Benson.

Trey Benson
Sickos Grade
64/100
Pre-draft #66

Florida State official athletic logoFlorida State· 6'0"· 216 lb· 4.39s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.8937
National · #372HS class · 2020
St. Joseph, MS
247Sports composite via CFBD
R3 · #66 · Arizona Cardinals

"Benson is the rare back whose best trait needs no projection: give him one clean crease and that 4.39 gear turns an ordinary zone handoff into a 70-yard answer in the open field."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Benson was a downhill one-cut back who ran Florida State's zone-heavy attack from shotgun and pistol, and the trait that organizes everything is long speed at 220 pounds. He presses the front side, keeps his eyes on the second-level defender, and needs only one hard plant to get square; once he clears the line his stride opens and pursuit angles die.

The secondary trait is contact tolerance rather than creativity. He finishes falling forward and runs through arm tackles, but he is not a jitterbug who wins in a phone booth. On passing downs he is a functional check-down target and a willing if uneven blocker. The signature is the chunk run: he turned ordinary blocking into 30-yard plays more often than anyone in his class.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Outside and mid zone rushing attack with play-action bootleg carryover

Shotgun single backPistolSplit zone leadThird-down checkdown
Best role

Year 1: complementary explosive back on 8-12 touches with zone-run and screen packages. Ceiling: 1A in a rotation that leans on his chunk-play rate.

Wrong fit

A gap-heavy power/duo offense that asks him to grind interior yardage between the tackles on 20 carries and to solo-block edge blitzers on obvious passing downs.

Best used behind a zone line that gives him a clean front-side read; his value drops when the design forces improvisation.

03Film room

Trey Benson 2023 Regular Season Highlights

Junior-year reel showing the one-cut decisiveness and long speed on chunk runs.

Film Room: FSU RB Trey Benson vs. Louisville - All Touches

Every-touch cut-up against a physical front; good look at vision and contact balance.

Trey Benson 200-yard rushing performance (Florida State)

Career-best rushing game featuring multiple explosive breakaway runs.

04The evaluation

Benson is a big-framed home-run back whose football identity is decisiveness plus speed, not elusiveness. He arrived at Oregon as a four-star, lost 2020 to a catastrophic knee injury that shredded his ACL, MCL and both menisci, carried six times in 2021, and transferred to Tallahassee to rebuild the whole profile.

He did rebuild it. Back-to-back 900-yard seasons in Mike Norvell's offense, 6.43 yards per carry as a sophomore and 14 rushing touchdowns as a junior, established him as the engine of an ACC championship team. The 2023 tape adds a real receiving element (20 catches) and shows a back who can carry a game plan, but it also shows tight hips in the hole, guessy interior vision on gap concepts, and pass protection that is more effort than technique.

The board loved the athletic answer. A 4.39 forty at 216 pounds validated everything the tape suggested about home-run ability, and most evaluators slotted him as the second or third back off the board in a deep class. Arizona taking him at 66 was not a reach; it was a team buying explosive complement to James Conner rather than a bell-cow replacement, and it accepted the medical file as the price of the speed.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Home-run speed

    a 4.39 forty at 216 pounds is not a workout number; it shows up on tape as 40-, 50- and 70-yard runs against ACC defensive backs with angles.

  2. 02

    Decisive one-cut runner

    presses, plants once and gets vertical without wasted steps, which makes him a plug-and-play fit in outside and mid zone schemes.

  3. 03

    Build for the workload

    thick 220-pound frame with a low pad level through contact; he falls forward and rarely gets stopped by the first arm tackle.

  4. 04

    Chunk-play production

    averaged 6.43 yards per carry in 2022 and posted 14 rushing touchdowns in 2023 while sharing a crowded FSU backfield.

  5. 05

    Growing receiving value

    20 catches for 227 yards as a junior showed reliable hands on checkdowns and enough route feel to stay on the field on third down.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Interior vision

    sees the front-side hole cleanly but can guess on gap and duo concepts, cutting back into traffic instead of trusting the design.

  2. 02

    Limited make-you-miss

    lateral agility and short-area quickness lag behind his top speed; he wins with pace, not with creativity in a crowded box.

  3. 03

    Pass protection technique

    willing and physical, but he ducks his head and lunges against blitzing linebackers, losing anchor and giving up the edge.

  4. 04

    Medical file

    the 2020 multi-ligament knee injury cost a full season and it remains the biggest variable on his long-term durability at the position.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'0"
Weight
216 lb
40 yd
4.39s
Vertical
33.5"
Broad
10'2"
06Athletic profilevs. RB on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.39sp50
Vertical
33.5inp50
Broad jump
122inp50
Three-cone
s
Shuttle
s
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGAttYdsTDRecRecYds
2021Oregon10622100
2022Florida State13154990913144
2023Florida State131569061420227
Career3631619182433371

Verified against cfbstats.com season pages (Oregon 2021, Florida State 2022-2023); season totals sum to career line. Redshirted 2020 after a multi-ligament knee injury.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2023
21.2%of team plays
88 percentile at positionFlorida State
Pass plays · 5.4%Run plays · 37.5%Third down · 7.1%Passing downs · 8.9%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Rachaad WhiteTampa Bay Buccaneers

Rotational-to-committee back whose production swings with blocking quality and passing-down usage.

/ Ceiling
Javonte WilliamsDallas Cowboys

Same thick frame and contact balance, with the burst to break the run once he clears the second level.

/ Floor
Jerick McKinnonKansas City Chiefs

Athletic complement whose career is defined by knee injuries and limited annual touch counts.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
0
Career AV

Arizona used Benson exactly as scouted in 2024, as the change-of-pace behind James Conner rather than as an every-down back: 63 carries for 291 yards and a touchdown plus six catches, with flashes of the long speed but almost no volume. Year two was supposed to be the jump. When Conner went down with a season-ending foot injury in Week 3, Benson inherited the starting job, having already popped a 52-yard run at New Orleans in Week 1, and finished his four games with 29 carries for 160 yards and 13 catches. Then a knee injury against Seattle in Week 4 sent him to injured reserve, arthroscopic meniscus surgery followed, and Arizona let his practice window expire in December without activating him.

Two seasons in, the evaluation is unresolved rather than wrong. The speed translated and the efficiency, 5.5 yards per carry in 2025, hinted at the back the board projected, but availability has now taken two bites out of him and he has never carried a full workload. The knee history that scouts priced into the third round is the exact thing that has defined his pro career so far, and the verdict on pick 66 is still open.

Data note: Verified against cfbstats.com season pages (Oregon 2021, Florida State 2022-2023); season totals sum to career line. Redshirted 2020 after a multi-ligament knee injury.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile