Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2024 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2024R6 · #194
TE· Round 6

Tanner
Mclachlan.

Tanner McLachlan
Sickos Grade
46/100

Arizona official athletic logoArizona· 6'5"· 244 lb· 4.61s 40

R6 · #194 · CIN

"A walk-on who broke Gronkowski's Arizona reception record on feel and hands alone, then found out that round six only keeps the tight ends who can block or cover kicks."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Move tight end who lived in the flex and slot alignments at Arizona and made his money as a chain-mover on the second level. A long strider rather than a burst athlete, he stems defenders with pace changes, sinks late on option and dig routes, and gives the quarterback a wide, quiet catch radius over the middle.

The secondary trait is run-after-catch balance — he plays through the first arm tackle and finishes forward. As a blocker he is willing and technically sound on the move, but he plays with more length than pop and gets stalemated by heavy edge setters. The signature is timing: he found the soft spot against zone and turned third-and-medium into a first down.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

West Coast / play-action offense that flexes its second tight end into the slot

Flex TESlotWingMove Y
Best role

Year 1: TE3 and core special teams body while he adds functional in-line strength. Ceiling: a dependable TE2 who plays 300-400 snaps as the zone-beating third-down target.

Wrong fit

A 12-personnel, gap-scheme run offense that asks its second tight end to block a 6-technique on early downs — he cannot anchor there.

Value rises in a passing game with heavy option routes and play-action crossers; drops sharply in any scheme where TE2 is a blocking job first.

03Film room

Tanner McLachlan | TE | Arizona | 2023 Highlights

Senior-season reel: option routes, digs and run-after-catch over the middle.

Tanner McLachlan | 84 | Arizona Wildcats TE

Full-cut Arizona tape showing alignment variety and catch-point work.

Tanner McLachlan Highlights - Welcome to Cincinnati

Draft-day reel produced after the Bengals took him at 194.

04The evaluation

A late-blooming pass-catching tight end whose football identity is reliability rather than explosion. Two years as a walk-on-turned-starter at Arizona produced a body of work built on route feel, hands and understanding of coverage, not on athletic overwhelm.

The production curve is unusual: four quiet FCS years at Southern Utah interrupted by a torn ACL, then 34 catches for 456 yards in his first Arizona season and 45 catches for 528 yards with four scores as a senior — enough to break Rob Gronkowski's school record for career receptions by a tight end. He tested adequately at the Combine (4.61 in the forty at 6-5, 244) and looked exactly like the tape: smooth, not sudden. The flags were age, a thin frame for in-line duty and the absence of a true separator trait against man coverage.

Boards had him in the fifth-to-seventh-round band as a TE2 developmental piece. Cincinnati taking him at 194 was a fair, low-risk swing on a quarterback-friendly target who needed a redshirt year in an NFL weight room before anyone could ask him to block a defensive end.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Hands and catch radius

    plucks away from his frame at 6-5 and finishes contested grabs over the middle without letting the ball into his chest.

  2. 02

    Zone feel

    reads leverage and settles in the soft spot on option and dig routes, giving the quarterback an on-time answer against match coverage.

  3. 03

    Run after catch

    plays through the first arm tackle with balance and pad control, converting short crossers into chain-moving gains.

  4. 04

    Route pacing

    uses tempo changes and late stems instead of raw burst to create the half-yard he needs at the top of the stem.

  5. 05

    Football character

    walk-on at Arizona who earned a scholarship and set the school's tight end reception record in two seasons of real snaps.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    In-line blocking power

    willing and technically sound on the move, but he gets stalemated by heavy edge setters and loses the leverage battle late.

  2. 02

    Separation vs man

    no burst out of the break, so physical defenders can ride him through the route and shrink the window.

  3. 03

    Play strength at the stem

    press-heavy defenders reroute him and disrupt the timing that his whole game depends on.

  4. 04

    Age and runway

    he entered the league at 25 with only two Power Five seasons, leaving little margin for a slow developmental curve.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'5"
Weight
244 lb
40 yd
4.61s
Vertical
35"
Broad
9'9"
06Athletic profilevs. TE on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.61sp50
Vertical
35inp50
Broad jump
117inp50
Three-cone
s
Shuttle
s
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2019Southern Utah3480
2021Southern Utah4121202
2022Arizona12344562
2023Arizona13455284
Career299411528

Arizona seasons verified vs cfbstats (2022: 12 G, 34-456-2; 2023: 13 G, 45-528-4). Southern Utah FCS seasons from school bio; 2019 game count unverified (null). 2020 FCS season not played (COVID); 2021 fall lost to a torn ACL.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2023
6.4%of team plays
95 percentile at positionArizona
Pass plays · 11.4%Run plays · 0.0%Third down · 9.8%Passing downs · 11.9%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Cole TurnerWAS

Big-bodied late-round pass catcher who lived on the roster fringe and never got a stable offensive role.

/ Ceiling
Tanner HudsonCIN

Same slot-flex, zone-feel archetype who carved out a real receiving role without blocking value.

/ Floor
Nick EubanksFA

Practice-squad tight end whose hands were real but who never won a special teams or blocking job.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV

Cincinnati kept him on the roster as a rookie but barely used him: two appearances in 2024, five offensive snaps and seventeen on special teams, with no targets. The 2025 camp ended with a waived/injured designation at final cuts, and the rest of the year was spent bouncing on and off the Chargers practice squad — signed and released three separate times, never elevated to a game day roster. Los Angeles let him go in May 2026. San Francisco gave him a one-year deal ahead of camp in July 2026 and waived him with an injury designation six days later, which is the whole story of his professional life so far: a body that has not stayed available long enough for the traits to be evaluated.

In hindsight the pick was reasonable and the outcome is a reminder of what round six actually buys. The tape said quarterback-friendly TE2 with real hands and no special athletic trait, and that profile only survives in the NFL if the player becomes a plus special teamer or an adequate in-line blocker in year one. Injuries never gave him that window. Nothing about the evaluation was wrong; the margin was simply too thin.

Data note: Arizona seasons verified vs cfbstats (2022: 12 G, 34-456-2; 2023: 13 G, 45-528-4). Southern Utah FCS seasons from school bio; 2019 game count unverified (null). 2020 FCS season not played (COVID); 2021 fall lost to a torn ACL.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile