Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2024 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2024R6 · #206
LB· Round 6

Nathaniel
Watson.

Nathaniel Watson
Sickos Grade
45.7/100

Mississippi St. official athletic logoMississippi St.· 6'2"· 233 lb· 4.63s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★☆☆stars.8681
National · #664HS class · 2018
Maplesville, AL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R6 · #206 · CLE

"The first SEC player ever to lead the conference in tackles and sacks in the same season, and a two-down thumper whose whole NFL case rests on contact and coverage teams."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Downhill inside linebacker who plays almost entirely between the tackles, reading his guard, filling the strong-side A-gap and finishing with real pop at the point of contact. He is a stack-and-shed thumper first: heavy hands, square shoulders, and a willingness to take on pulling guards rather than run around them. Play speed is better than his timed speed because he triggers early and rarely false-steps.

The second trait is the pressure package. Mississippi State turned him into a designed blitzer, and he times interior pressures with a veteran's feel for snap count and protection slide. Against the pass he is a zone-drop defender with limited range, so the value shows on early downs and in green-dog situations rather than in space.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Single-gap 4-3 or 3-4 under front that plays its Mike downhill and lets him blitz the A-gap on early downs

Mike (stack)Strong-side ILBA-gap blitzerKick/punt coverage
Best role

Year 1: core special teamer and base-package run thumper in heavy personnel. Ceiling: 400-snap early-down starter who leads a defense in tackles when the nickel comes off the field.

Wrong fit

Match-quarters or heavy nickel systems that ask the second linebacker to carry tight ends up the seam and mirror backs in man; his zone depth and change of direction do not hold up in those calls.

Value peaks when a defensive coordinator schemes his pressures rather than asking him to win one-on-one.

03Film room

Nathaniel Watson vs LSU (2023)

Full-game reel from his SEC Defensive Player of the Year season: downhill fills, A-gap pressures and finishing tackles.

NFL Draft Film: Nathaniel Watson 2022 Highlights

2022 cutups showing the stack-and-shed run defense and early blitz timing.

Nathaniel Watson Mississippi State Highlights

Career highlight package covering his run-down production in Starkville.

04The evaluation

A sixth-year senior who arrived in Starkville in 2018 and left as the most productive defender in the SEC, Watson is a classic old-school Mike: thick through the chest, comfortable in traffic, and defined by contact rather than coverage. He looks the part of a run-down linebacker and plays exactly to that identity.

The production is the resume. He led the SEC with 137 tackles and 10 sacks in 2023 and became the first player in conference history to lead the league in both categories in the same year, taking AP SEC Defensive Player of the Year honors. That sack total came almost entirely on scheme blitzes, which is the flag: strip the free runs and the pass-rush profile shrinks. Coverage reps were similarly uneven, with late depth in zone and clear trouble mirroring backs.

The board read him as a two-down run defender with special teams value, and the sixth round is exactly where that profile lives. Cleveland took the tackles, the toughness and the blitz timing, and accepted that third down would belong to somebody else.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Run diagnosis

    Reads the guard and triggers downhill with almost no wasted footwork, arriving at the mesh point before blockers can climb to the second level.

  2. 02

    Contact tolerance

    Takes on lead blockers square, keeps his frame clean and consistently drops ballcarriers on impact rather than riding them forward.

  3. 03

    Blitz timing

    Times interior pressures with a veteran's clock, hitting the A-gap on the snap and finishing as a real interior rusher on scheme blitzes.

  4. 04

    Tackle production

    Led the SEC with 137 tackles in 2023 after 114 the year before, a two-year run of volume that shows genuine range within the box.

  5. 05

    Special teams value

    Physical, willing cover player who translated immediately to kick and punt coverage as a rookie with nine special teams stops.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Coverage range

    Zone drops are shallow and late, and he struggles to carry seams or recover when routes cross behind him in the middle of the field.

  2. 02

    Man matchups

    Lacks the hips and short-area burst to mirror backs out of the backfield, which caps him as a two-down player in nickel personnel.

  3. 03

    Rush independence

    Sacks came largely from schemed free runs; he has limited counters when a back or guard picks up the blitz cleanly.

  4. 04

    Play speed in space

    Timed 4.63 but plays tighter sideline to sideline, and perimeter runs regularly beat him to the edge when he has to redirect.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'2"
Weight
233 lb
40 yd
4.63s
Vertical
31"
Broad
9'3"
06Athletic profilevs. LB on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.63sp50
Vertical
31inp50
Broad jump
111inp50
Three-cone
s
Shuttle
s
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGTklSkIntPDFF
2020Mississippi State11400010
2021Mississippi State12845010
2022Mississippi State131146111
2023Mississippi State1213710122
Career4837521253

Verified season by season on cfbstats; seasons sum exactly to the career line. Mississippi State credits him with 57 games and 379 tackles across 2018-23 including sparse freshman and 2019 appearances that cfbstats does not itemize; those unverified games are excluded rather than estimated.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Blake CashmanMinnesota Vikings

Rotational box linebacker whose value swings between run-down starter and special teams core depending on health.

/ Ceiling
Nick BoltonKansas City Chiefs

Same downhill trigger and tackle volume, but Bolton's short-area quickness let him stay on the field on third down in a way Watson never has.

/ Floor
Jordan KunaszykFree agent

Physical thumper who never cracked a defensive rotation and carved out years purely on coverage units.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV

Cleveland waived him at the first cutdown of his rookie year, brought him back on the practice squad two days later and elevated him to the active roster by early October. He appeared in 14 games with one start in 2024 and lived on special teams, where he logged nine coverage tackles including a three-stop game against Kansas City, and stayed almost entirely off the defensive call sheet behind the veterans. Then 2025 disappeared: a biceps tear in an August practice put him on season-ending injured reserve before the opener, and he watched a rebuilt Browns linebacker room take shape without him. He returned to training camp in August 2026 still under contract and still fighting for the same job description.

In hindsight the pick has done exactly what a sixth-round thumper is supposed to do, no more and no less. The evaluation was right on both ends: the tape said run-down enforcer and core special teamer, and that is precisely the role he has filled when healthy. What the profile could not survive was a modern defense that plays nickel by default and a lost season at the worst possible moment in a young career.

Data note: Verified season by season on cfbstats; seasons sum exactly to the career line. Mississippi State credits him with 57 games and 379 tackles across 2018-23 including sparse freshman and 2019 appearances that cfbstats does not itemize; those unverified games are excluded rather than estimated.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile