Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2023 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2023Consensus #079
WR· Round 3

Josh
Downs.

Josh Downs
Sickos Grade
63.8/100
Pre-draft #79

North Carolina official athletic logoNorth Carolina· 5'9"· 171 lb· 4.48s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9563
National · #95HS class · 2020
North Gwinnett, GA
247Sports composite via CFBD
R3 · #79 · Indianapolis Colts

"A 171-pound slot who plays like the biggest competitor on the field: separation on demand underneath, and a catch radius that has no business belonging to him."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Downs is a full-time slot who aligned inside on nearly every North Carolina snap, working option routes, choice concepts and quick game in a spread offense that fed him volume. The primary trait is short-area quickness: he sinks his hips, changes direction without gathering, and wins leverage in the first three steps.

The secondary trait is competitiveness at the catch point. For a 5-9, 171-pound receiver he plays with a startling catch radius, extends away from his frame and finishes through contact over the middle. He is a third-down and red-zone factor rather than a vertical stressor, and he adds punt-return value. The athletic ceiling is quickness-based, not long-speed based, and the signature is separation on demand.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

A quick-game, timing-based passing offense in 11 personnel that plays with a full-time slot and lets him work option routes against nickel leverage on early downs and third down.

SlotReduced splitMotion/jetPunt returner
Best role

Year 1: starting slot with 90-plus targets on quick-game and option concepts. Ceiling: an 80-catch chain-mover who is the offense's primary third-down answer.

Wrong fit

A heavy-play-action, boundary-oriented offense in 12 personnel that asks its third receiver to block on the edge and win outside against press corners.

His value is tied to being schemed inside; the more an offense detaches him to the perimeter, the less of the profile survives.

03Film room

Sam Howell finds Josh Downs for the touchdown

North Carolina tape showing the separation quickness and finish that defined his 2021 breakout.

Josh Downs highlights — 2025 NFL season

Slot work with Indianapolis: option routes, third-down conversions and contested grabs over the middle.

Colts at Texans — 2024 Week 8 highlights

Downs' 122-yard afternoon, the best game of his career to date.

04The evaluation

Downs is a slot receiver in the purest sense: inside alignment, option routes, and a game built on winning the first three yards. He is small and light, and he never pretended otherwise — the identity is quickness, hands and toughness in the middle of the field rather than perimeter size or take-the-top-off speed.

The production carried the evaluation. After seven catches as a freshman in 2020, he exploded for 101 receptions and 1,335 yards with eight touchdowns in 2021, then followed with 94 catches, 1,029 yards and 11 touchdowns in 2022 despite missing time and opting out of the Holiday Bowl to prepare for the draft. Career: 202 catches, 2,483 yards, 22 scores in 34 games. The flags were obvious — 171 pounds, a 30 3/8-inch arm length, a route tree that lived almost entirely inside, and questions about press and durability against NFL nickel bodies.

The combine did not change the story so much as confirm it: 4.48 with a 1.49 ten-yard split, a 38.5-inch vertical and a 131-inch broad, with no bench, three-cone or shuttle. Boards had him as a mid-Day 2 slot with a defined role and a limited ceiling. Indianapolis taking him at 79 was a bet that the role was worth a starter's snaps.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Short-area quickness

    Sinks and redirects without gathering, which lets him win option routes and choice concepts against nickels who cannot mirror the first three steps.

  2. 02

    Catch radius

    Extends well outside his frame for a 5-9 receiver and plucks high and low throws cleanly rather than trapping them against his body.

  3. 03

    Middle-of-the-field toughness

    Works the seams and dig windows knowing contact is coming, and finishes catches through the hit on third down.

  4. 04

    Volume production

    195 receptions across his last two seasons at North Carolina, a workload that proves both durability at his size and target-earning trust.

  5. 05

    Return value

    Handled punt returns in 2021 and 2022, adding a special-teams role that raises the floor for an undersized slot on a 46-man gameday roster.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Playing weight

    At 171 pounds he can be rerouted by physical nickels and dragged down by first contact, and the collision volume of a slot role is a durability question.

  2. 02

    Alignment limitation

    Almost all of his college value came from inside, and there is little tape of him beating press or winning contested balls on the perimeter.

  3. 03

    Long speed

    The 4.48 is functional rather than threatening; he stresses defenses horizontally and underneath, not over the top on go routes.

  4. 04

    Incomplete testing

    He skipped the bench, three-cone and shuttle at the combine and published no pro-day numbers, leaving the agility and strength profile partly unmeasured.

07Athletic testing
Height
5'9"
Weight
171 lb
40 yd
4.48s
Vertical
38.5"
Broad
10'11"
06Athletic profilevs. WR on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.48sp50
Vertical
38.5inp50
Broad jump
131inp50
Three-cone
s
Shuttle
s
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2020North Carolina1071193
2021North Carolina1310113358
2022North Carolina1194102911
Career34202248322

Verified against cfbstats.com season pages: receptions (202), yards (2,483) and touchdowns (22) sum exactly across 2020-2022. Punt returns: 15-149 in 2021, 10-133 in 2022. Rushing lines for 2021-2022 are not published in a verifiable source and are left blank. The 2022 total excludes the Holiday Bowl, which he skipped to declare.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2022
14.1%of team plays
99 percentile at positionNorth Carolina
Pass plays · 25.2%Run plays · 0.3%Third down · 18.9%Passing downs · 20.2%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Hunter RenfrowLas Vegas Raiders

A reliable option-route slot who moves the chains at a high rate but is capped by frame and long speed.

/ Ceiling
Wes WelkerNew England Patriots

The size-defying volume slot who becomes a quarterback's security blanket and posts triple-digit target seasons.

/ Floor
Trent TaylorSan Francisco 49ers

If the body cannot absorb slot collisions, the outcome is a rotational fourth receiver and return specialist.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
3
Career AV

A three-year starting slot in Indianapolis who set the Colts rookie receptions record in 2023 (68-771-2), peaked in 2024 (72-803-5) and dipped in 2025 (58-566-4) as the Colts went 8-9. Career through 2025: 47 games, 198 catches, 2,140 yards, 11 touchdowns.

Downs started producing immediately. As a rookie in 2023 he played all 17 games with nine starts and caught 68 passes for 771 yards and two touchdowns on 98 targets, breaking Bill Brooks' franchise rookie receptions record while catching passes from a rotating cast of quarterbacks. In 2024 a high-ankle sprain suffered in a training-camp seven-on-seven cost him three games, and he still posted a career-best 72 catches for 803 yards and five touchdowns, including a 122-yard game at Houston. In 2025, with Daniel Jones opening the season as the starter and the Colts finishing 8-9 and out of the playoffs, his volume slipped to 58 catches for 566 yards and four touchdowns.

In hindsight the 79th pick has been solid without becoming a bargain. Indianapolis got exactly the player the tape promised: a full-time slot who separates underneath, converts third downs and never wins outside. The frame concerns proved half-right — he absorbed the workload but the ankle cost him a season's rhythm, and defenses have learned to sit on the option routes. Entering 2026 in the final year of his rookie deal with an extension unresolved, he is a good starter on a team still searching for the quarterback who would make him a great one.

Data note: Verified against cfbstats.com season pages: receptions (202), yards (2,483) and touchdowns (22) sum exactly across 2020-2022. Punt returns: 15-149 in 2021, 10-133 in 2022. Rushing lines for 2021-2022 are not published in a verifiable source and are left blank. The 2022 total excludes the Holiday Bowl, which he skipped to declare.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile