Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2023 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2023Consensus #039
WR· Round 2

Jonathan
Mingo.

Jonathan Mingo
Sickos Grade
71.4/100
Pre-draft #39

Ole Miss official athletic logoOle Miss· 6'2"· 220 lb· 4.46s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9157
National · #216HS class · 2019
Brandon, MS
247Sports composite via CFBD
R2 · #39 · Carolina Panthers

"Carolina paid a starter's price for a one-year producer whose tape promised mass and straight lines, then asked him to win the routes his college offense never made him run."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Big-slot and boundary Z who wins with mass and contact balance rather than separation quickness. Ole Miss used him as the physical answer in a tempo spread: bubble screens, glance concepts and slot fades that let him get downhill with a head of steam. He builds speed in a straight line and finishes through contact at the catch point with strong, late hands.

The secondary trait is run-game utility — he blocks with intent from the slot and will dig out a safety on perimeter zone, which kept him on the field on early downs. As a route runner he is a builder, better on slants, posts and digs than on anything demanding a sudden stop. The signature is yards after catch through arm tackles: he plays like a big back once the ball is in his hands.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Play-action heavy offense with a manufactured-touch package that gets him the ball at speed instead of asking him to separate.

Big slotBoundary ZBubble/jet touchesWing on outside zone
Best role

Year 1: WR3 who blocks on early downs and takes designed touches. Ceiling: physical WR2 in a play-action offense.

Wrong fit

A timing-and-spacing passing game that lives on option routes and asks the slot to win one-on-one against nickel press.

The scheme has to create his leverage; he does not manufacture it himself.

03Film room

Jonathan Mingo 2022 Highlights | Ole Miss WR | 2023 NFL Draft Prospect

Senior-season cutups: slot fades, glance routes and yards after contact.

Jonathan Mingo 2022 Ole Miss Highlights

Full 2022 reel including the 247-yard game against Vanderbilt.

Jonathan Mingo Ole Miss WR Highlights || Physical Playmaker

Contact-balance compilation and perimeter blocking reps.

04The evaluation

Physical, high-cut receiver with an NFL frame and a fifth-year breakout, evaluated as a big-slot who could grow into a starting X in a scheme that manufactures touches. The football identity is contact: at the catch point, after the catch, and as a blocker. Nothing about the profile is finesse.

Production tells the story of a slow build. Twelve catches as a freshman, 27 in an injury-shortened sophomore year, then six games in 2021 before a foot injury ended it. The senior season was the evidence: 51 catches for 861 yards and five scores at nearly 17 yards a grab, including a 247-yard afternoon against Vanderbilt that put him on every board. The flags were the ones that always come with a one-year profile — a route tree that lived on verticals and slants, hands that fought the ball on off-target throws, and separation numbers that never matched the athletic testing.

Consensus had him as a late-first to early-second option with a wide range: teams that valued the frame, testing and blocking took him higher; teams that wanted a refined route runner had him in the third. Carolina, in the same draft they moved up for a quarterback, spent the 39th pick on the receiver they believed would be that quarterback's physical target. It was a bet on traits over separation.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Contact balance

    plays like a running back after the catch, running through arm tackles and finishing runs forward instead of looking for the sideline.

  2. 02

    Catch-point strength

    attacks the ball with late, strong hands and can win contested throws on slot fades and back-shoulder verticals.

  3. 03

    Deep-ball tracking

    adjusts smoothly over either shoulder on the go route and rarely lets the ball get into his frame downfield.

  4. 04

    Perimeter blocking

    willing and effective as a run-game blocker from the slot, sustaining on safeties and nickels on outside zone.

  5. 05

    Frame and testing profile

    6-2, 220 with legitimate straight-line speed for the size, an unusual combination in the 2023 receiver class.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Separation quickness

    high-cut and stiff in the hips, which shows up as tight breaks and late windows against press-man coverage.

  2. 02

    Route tree

    Ole Miss asked mostly for verticals, slants and manufactured touches, leaving the intermediate menu underdeveloped.

  3. 03

    Hands consistency

    will fight the ball on off-target throws and had drops on routine targets when he took his eyes downfield early.

  4. 04

    One-year production

    a single season above 400 receiving yards makes the projection lean heavily on traits rather than a track record.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'2"
Weight
220 lb
40 yd
4.46s
Vertical
39.5"
Broad
10'9"
Bench
22
06Athletic profilevs. WR on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.46sp50
Vertical
39.5inp50
Broad jump
129inp50
Three-cone
s
Shuttle
s
Bench
22repp50
08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2019Ole Miss121721
2020Ole Miss10273793
2021Ole Miss6223463
2022Ole Miss13518615
Career29112175812

Season lines verified on cfbstats (2020-2022) and the 2019 freshman receiving line via ESPN; cfbstats has no 2019 page for him, so freshman games played is left unverified rather than zero-filled. Career totals (112 rec / 1,758 yds / 12 TD) match the sum of the four seasons. The 2021 season ended after six games with a foot injury.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2022
7.3%of team plays
81 percentile at positionOle Miss
Pass plays · 16.5%Run plays · 0.8%Third down · 6.5%Passing downs · 6.2%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Terrace Marshall Jr.Carolina Panthers

Same size-speed profile and same problem — traits that test well but never turned into consistent separation at the NFL level.

/ Ceiling
Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts

The realistic ceiling if the route tree expands: a big-bodied possession starter who wins the catch point and moves the chains.

/ Floor
N'Keal HarryChicago Bears

The floor for a high-pick physical receiver without a route tree: a blocker and depth body who never finds a steady offensive role.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
1
Career AV

Mingo played in 15 games for the Carolina Panthers in his rookie season, starting 11. He recorded 23 receptions for 418 yards, but did not score a touchdown.

Carolina played him immediately, and the fit problem showed immediately. He started 12 games as a rookie in an offense with a rookie quarterback and almost no route structure, finishing 43 catches for 418 yards on 85 targets — no touchdowns, 9.7 yards a catch, one of the worst efficiency lines a second-round receiver has posted in years. The 2024 season went worse: nine games, 12 catches, then a November trade to Dallas for a fourth-round pick. Dallas gave him eight games and five catches. In 2025 he sat behind CeeDee Lamb, played six games with a single 25-yard reception, and landed on injured reserve with a PCL injury. He enters 2026 on a roster bubble with zero career touchdowns.

In hindsight the evaluation was right and the price was wrong. The tape said big body, straight lines, tough after the catch; the separation profile said role player. Carolina paid starter money in draft capital for the traits and then asked him to win routes in an offense that could not scheme him free — the exact environment the profile warned against. Yards-after-catch mass without a route tree needs a functioning play-caller and a defined manufactured-touch role, and he never got either. Two rounds later, this is a useful WR3 and core blocker instead of a cautionary tale.

Data note: Season lines verified on cfbstats (2020-2022) and the 2019 freshman receiving line via ESPN; cfbstats has no 2019 page for him, so freshman games played is left unverified rather than zero-filled. Career totals (112 rec / 1,758 yds / 12 TD) match the sum of the four seasons. The 2021 season ended after six games with a foot injury.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile