Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2023 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2023Consensus #009
DT· Round 1

Jalen
Carter.

Jalen Carter
Sickos Grade
88.2/100
Pre-draft #9

Georgia official athletic logoGeorgia· 6'3"· 314 lb

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★★stars.9911
National · #18HS class · 2020
Apopka, FL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R1 · #9 · Philadelphia Eagles

"The rarest thing in the class is not his power or his burst but the fact that a 300-pound man is routinely the first defender to a football running away from him."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Interior disruptor who lined up across Georgia's front — 3-technique on passing downs, head-up over the guard in base — and won with the rarest first step at 300-plus pounds in the class. His get-off beats the snap, his hands are violent and independent, and he converts speed to power on contact, walking a guard backward without losing his own leverage.

The second gear shows up laterally: he chases down the line, flattens on stretch runs and closes on scrambling quarterbacks like an edge player. Against the run he can stack and shed with long arms or spill the puller. The signature is wrecking a play from the back side — a 300-pounder who is often the first defender to a ball running away from him.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Attacking one-gap four-man front that lets him shoot a single gap upfield instead of holding two.

3-technique1-techniqueHead-up noseNASCAR interior
Best role

Year 1: 40-snap interior rusher inside a veteran rotation. Ceiling: every-down 3-technique who is the best player on a championship defense.

Wrong fit

Two-gap 3-4 that asks him to read-and-react at nose and eat double teams as his primary job.

His value is highest when the plan is to let him go get it, not to keep him clean for someone else.

03Film room

Most DOMINANT Defensive Lineman in College Football || Georgia DL Jalen Carter 2022 Highlights ᴴᴰ

Jalen Carter: Georgia Highlights | 9th Overall Pick In The 2023 NFL Draft | CBS Sports

Brick Wall 🧱 || Jalen Carter 2022 Georgia Highlights 🐶 || HD

04The evaluation

Carter was the best football player in the 2023 class regardless of position — a foundational interior defender with the burst of an edge rusher and the anchor of a nose tackle. Evaluators did not debate the tape; they debated the person and the ceiling of a player whose raw production never matched what he did to games.

Georgia used him as one piece of a loaded rotation, so his counting numbers stayed modest: 83 tackles, 18.5 tackles for loss and 6.0 sacks across 38 games, capped by 7.0 TFL and 3.0 sacks over 13 games on the 2022 national champions. Those totals undersell the film, where he routinely ate double teams and freed teammates for cleaner rushes. The flags were real and off the field: a misdemeanor racing charge tied to the January 2023 crash that killed teammate Devin Willock and a staffer, and a Pro Day where he weighed in nine pounds heavier and could not finish drills.

The board consensus never wavered on the grade — top-three talent — only on the risk. Teams re-sorted him into the middle of the round rather than off it. Philadelphia traded up one spot with Chicago, paying a 2024 fourth-rounder, to add him to a defensive front that could absorb a young player without asking him to save it in Year 1.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Elite first step

    the quickest get-off among interior linemen in the class, consistently beating guards to the landmark before they can set their hands.

  2. 02

    Power conversion

    turns that burst into a bull rush, collapsing the pocket's interior and squeezing the quarterback's stepping room without needing a counter.

  3. 03

    Backside range

    flattens down the line on stretch and zone runs and is often the first big man to the ball on plays going away from him.

  4. 04

    Hand usage

    independent, violent hands that swipe, club and rip, so blockers rarely land a clean two-hand fit on his frame.

  5. 05

    Alignment flexibility

    legitimate at 3-technique, 1-technique and head-up nose, which lets a coordinator move him to attack a weak guard.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Thin production

    18.5 career TFL and 6.0 sacks is modest for a top-10 interior grade, even accounting for Georgia's deep rotation.

  2. 02

    Conditioning questions

    weighed in nine pounds heavier at his Pro Day and pulled out of drills, which fed doubts about year-round professionalism.

  3. 03

    Off-field flags

    a misdemeanor racing charge tied to the fatal January 2023 crash forced every team to run its own character evaluation.

  4. 04

    Pad level dips

    when he plays high out of his stance he loses his leverage advantage and can be washed by a good down block.

08College production
YrTeamGTklSkIntPDFF
2020Georgia10140000
2021Georgia15373010
2022Georgia13323032
Career38836042

Parsed from Sports-Reference CFB career page via Firecrawl.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Chris JonesKansas City Chiefs

Big-bodied interior disruptor whose pressure rate matters more than his raw sack column.

/ Ceiling
Aaron DonaldLos Angeles Rams

The get-off and backside range live in the same neighborhood, even if Donald's relentlessness is its own tier.

/ Floor
Marcell DareusBuffalo Bills

Immense talent whose conditioning and focus decide whether he is a Pro Bowler or a rotational body.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
1
All-Pro
0
Seasons
1
Career AV

Jalen Carter had an impactful rookie season as a defensive tackle for the Philadelphia Eagles, earning a Pro Bowl selection. He was a disruptive force on the interior defensive line.

Philadelphia dropped him into a rotation with Fletcher Cox and Jordan Davis and let the tape do the talking. He posted 33 tackles and 6.0 sacks in 16 rookie games and made the PFWA All-Rookie team. Year 2 was the leap in role rather than counting stats: 42 tackles and 4.5 sacks in 16 games, second-team AP All-Pro, a first Pro Bowl and a Super Bowl LIX ring earned largely by what he did to Kansas City's interior without an unblocked rusher on the field. In 2025 he opened the season with an ejection on the first snap for spitting at Dak Prescott, then missed time and finished with 21 tackles, 5 TFL and 3.0 sacks across 11 games, adding a sack in the divisional loss to San Francisco and a second Pro Bowl nod as a starter.

In hindsight the pick was as clean as a top-10 defensive tackle gets. The risk teams priced in was never about football; it was about maturity, and the 2025 ejection was the one time it cost his team. Everything else has validated the evaluation: a disruptor whose value shows up in the sack totals of the players next to him more than in his own line. Chicago's one-spot slide netted a fourth-rounder; Philadelphia got an All-Pro anchor on a rookie deal for a championship defense.

Data note: Parsed from Sports-Reference CFB career page via Firecrawl.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile