Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2023 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2023Consensus #004
QB· Round 1

Anthony
Richardson.

Anthony Richardson
Sickos Grade
86.2/100
Pre-draft #4

Florida official athletic logoFlorida· 6'4"· 244 lb· 4.43s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9204
National · #207HS class · 2020
Eastside, FL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R1 · #4 · Indianapolis Colts

"The most athletic quarterback ever to test at the Combine, sold on a ceiling nobody could measure and a floor everybody could see — Indianapolis bought the tools and never got the runway to build them."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Richardson ran Florida's spread-option attack as a 6-foot-4, 244-pound quarterback asked to threaten defenses as a designed runner first, dropback passer second. The arm is a howitzer: he drives the boundary comeback off his back foot with velocity most starters cannot match with perfect feet. Underneath it the mechanics wobble — long delivery, inconsistent front foot, ball carriage dropping when the pocket gets loud.

As a runner he is a different sport: 4.43 speed, one-cut burst on zone read, contact balance that sheds arm tackles. His best throws come on the move to his right. The separator is the physical profile itself, but the operational side — progression speed, intermediate touch, rhythm accuracy — lagged badly behind the tools.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Spread-based play-action and RPO offense with a heavy designed-quarterback-run menu, built to simplify reads and put the ball in his hands as a runner in short yardage and the red zone.

Shotgun spreadZone-readRPO triggerPlay-action bootQB power / short yardage
Best role

Year 1 as a package starter behind a veteran bridge, running a condensed half-field read tree while the mechanics get rebuilt; ceiling is a franchise dual-threat quarterback who wins the run game math every snap.

Wrong fit

A timing-based, under-center West Coast offense that lives on rhythm accuracy, full-field progressions and a compressed dropback game — it removes his run leverage and exposes the two weakest traits on the profile.

The scheme has to protect the middle of the field: he needs defined reads, motion tells and a play-action base, not a system that asks him to solve disguised two-high coverage from the pocket on third down.

03Film room

Florida QB Anthony Richardson 2022 Highlights

Full 2022 season cut-up of his lone year as Florida's starter.

Anthony Richardson Full Career Highlights, Florida Gators 2020-2022

Career reel spanning all three Gainesville seasons.

Anthony Richardson's FULL 2023 NFL Scouting Combine On-Field Workouts

The record-setting Combine workout that reshaped his draft stock.

04The evaluation

Richardson entered the 2023 cycle as the most physically gifted quarterback prospect in a decade and one of the least experienced. A Gainesville native who stayed home, he waited behind Kyle Trask and Emory Jones before finally taking the Florida offense in 2022, and even then he was more idea than product: a quarterback who could win a game by himself, and lose one the same way.

The 2022 tape carried both extremes. He opened by beating No. 7 Utah with three total touchdowns, then threw two picks the next week against Kentucky. He finished at 53.8 percent with 17 touchdowns and nine interceptions, adding 654 yards and nine scores on the ground — a good runner and a below-average passer. The accuracy flags were structural, not situational: misses on rhythm throws, drifting eyes, slow answers against disguised coverage. Then he ran 4.43 with a 40.5-inch vertical at 244 pounds.

Boards split hard. Some had him first overall on ceiling alone; others graded a Day 2 developmental project who needed a redshirt year. Consensus landed him top five with a loud disclaimer. Indianapolis, with Shane Steichen fresh off building around Jalen Hurts, took the swing at No. 4 — a bet that scheme and patience could buy the reps Florida never gave him.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Elite arm talent

    generates high-end velocity from a variety of platforms and can drive the boundary comeback or deep out without stepping into it.

  2. 02

    Historic athletic profile

    4.43 speed and a 40.5-inch vertical at 244 pounds, the most explosive quarterback testing line ever recorded at the Combine.

  3. 03

    Designed-run weapon

    a true short-yardage and red-zone hammer whose zone-read and quarterback-power reps force defenses to add a defender to the box.

  4. 04

    Escapability

    slides and climbs through muddied pockets, breaks the first arm tackle, and creates real off-schedule throws moving to his right.

  5. 05

    Play-action shot maker

    layers deep crossers and post-corner throws with touch when his base is clean and the first read is there.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Accuracy volatility

    completed just 53.8 percent as a starter, with misses that came on rhythm throws and open windows rather than contested ones.

  2. 02

    Slow processing

    hangs on his first read, is late to work backside, and gets baited by disguised two-high and late safety rotation.

  3. 03

    Mechanical inconsistency

    long delivery, inconsistent front foot, and a ball carriage that drops under his waist when the pocket gets loud.

  4. 04

    Almost no starting resume

    13 career starts and one full season running an offense, leaving evaluators projecting on tools instead of tape.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'4"
Weight
244 lb
40 yd
4.43s
Vertical
40.5"
Broad
10'9"
Relative Athletic Score
9.99
/10 · official

Relative Athletic Score (Kent Lee Platte) benchmarks combine/pro-day numbers against every measured prospect at the position since 1987. 10.00 is elite; 5.00 is average.

06Athletic profilevs. QB on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.43sp50
Vertical
40.5inp50
Broad jump
129inp50
Three-cone
s
Shuttle
s
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGCmpAttYdsTDInt
2020Florida5122711
2021Florida8386452965
2022Florida121763272549179
Career2521539331052415

Verified season-by-season against cfbstats.com official Florida pages; season sums reconcile exactly with career totals.

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2022
54.8%of team plays
87 percentile at positionFlorida
Pass plays · 95.4%Run plays · 22.1%Third down · 69.9%Passing downs · 67.8%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Josh FreemanTampa Bay Buccaneers

Big-armed, big-bodied starter with flashes of brilliance whose accuracy and decision-making never stabilize enough to hold the job past the rookie contract.

/ Ceiling
Cam NewtonCarolina Panthers

The realistic dream: an oversized dual-threat who bullies defenses on designed runs and hits enough downfield shots to carry an offense to an MVP season.

/ Floor
Tyrod TaylorBuffalo Bills

The floor if the passing operation never catches up: a mobile, low-turnover backup who wins on legs and situational packages rather than as a full-time starter.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
3
Career AV

Anthony Richardson started four games for the Indianapolis Colts in his rookie season, showing dynamic playmaking ability before suffering a season-ending shoulder injury. He demonstrated high potential in limited action.

Indianapolis handed him the offense as a rookie and the flashes were real: four starts, 577 passing yards, three touchdowns and one interception, plus explosive runs that looked like a franchise arriving. Then a Grade 3 AC joint sprain in Week 5 ended the season and cost him the developmental year the profile needed. He returned as the 2024 Week 1 starter and the accuracy never resolved — 1,814 yards, eight touchdowns, 12 interceptions and a 61.6 passer rating across 11 starts, punctuated by a Week 8 sequence against Houston where he took himself out of a drive for a breather. Shane Steichen benched him for Joe Flacco, gave the job back late, then Indianapolis signed Daniel Jones in 2025 and Jones won camp outright. Richardson barely played, aggravated the shoulder in June, fractured an orbital bone in a pregame accident in October and finished on injured reserve as the Colts fell from 8-2 to 8-9.

The Colts declined his fifth-year option in April 2026, he asked for a trade nobody took, and he opened this camp fighting Riley Leonard for the backup job. In hindsight the miss was not the read on the tools — every word about the arm and the legs was accurate — but the assumption that a quarterback with 13 college starts would get a runway. He never did. Injuries erased the developmental reps, the accuracy floor never rose, and a franchise under pressure could not afford to wait.

Data note: Verified season-by-season against cfbstats.com official Florida pages; season sums reconcile exactly with career totals.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile