Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #059
WR· Round 2

Terrace
Marshall Jr..

Terrace Marshall Jr.
Sickos Grade
71.4/100
Pre-draft #59

LSU official athletic logoLSU

R2 · #59 · Carolina Panthers

"A 6'3" LSU receiver stuck behind Ja'Marr Chase and Justin Jefferson who broke out in 2020 on a bad team — a jump-ball X profile that lived on his frame more than his releases."Pre-draft read

01Play style

He functions as a size/speed vertical receiver, primarily from the Z position or as a big-slot option. He consistently wins with linear speed and leverages his length for contested catches, utilizing body positioning in the red zone. His route tree centers on vertical concepts, deep overs, slot fades, and backside X isolation; full-field separation on dig, curl, or comeback routes against press-man is a projection.

He is a long strider with a 33 1/2-inch catch radius, playing taller than his 205 pounds in scoring territory. He is not used as a motion or jet-sweep weapon, nor is he a technician after the catch. His role involves volume as a downfield target and securing red-zone body catches, a usage requiring a rhythmic quarterback and clean protection to maximize effectiveness.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Vertical passing game, ideally with an emphasis on a boundary X receiver and red-zone targets.

X-receiverBig Slot WRRed-zone threat
Best role

Year 1 contributor as a rotational outside WR in a vertical-heavy scheme, with the ceiling to develop into a secondary X-receiver target.

Wrong fit

A West Coast timing-based offense that demands precise, sudden breaks and consistent full-field separation on intermediate routes.

Marshall's size and speed project best as a vertical, contested-catch threat who can be moved around, but his route-running limitations against press-man limit his ceiling.

03Film room

LSU WR Terrace Marshall Jr. 2020 Highlights

Full 2020 LSU reel: 10-TD seven-game sample as the primary target, red-zone fades and vertical wins that framed the top-60 grade.

Terrace Marshall Jr. Scouting Report (2021 NFL Draft)

Independent scouting cut breaking down size/speed traits, route-tree limits and Day-2 projection into Carolina.

Welcome to Carolina — Terrace Marshall Jr. Career Highlights

Pre-draft career reel packaged around the Panthers pick, showing the LSU role progression and vertical target profile.

04The evaluation

Terrace Marshall Jr. projects as a vertical and big-slot receiver, offering a valuable downfield threat and red-zone target. His combination of size and 4.38 pro-day speed indicates a player capable of stretching defenses and winning contested catches, providing a clear role for an NFL offense to build upon.

Marshall was a consistent contributor at LSU, emerging in 2019 within a national championship offense where he totaled 46 catches for 671 yards and 13 touchdowns. He led the team in 2020 with 48 receptions, 731 yards, and 10 touchdowns in seven games. His usage emphasized big-slot and backside X alignment, and red-zone fade concepts, rather than full-field X responsibilities, suggesting his ability to achieve full-field separation against press-man coverage was more projection than proven.

Evaluators recognized his elite size/speed profile, which placed him in the top tier on many media boards. However, concerns existed regarding his route tree and the limited sample of full-field X responsibilities against press-man. He was ultimately drafted in the second round, 59th overall, by the Carolina Panthers, where he was envisioned as a complementary vertical threat opposite Robby Anderson and D.J. Moore.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Boundary Receiver Frame

    He measures 6-3, 205 pounds with 33-inch arms, providing size for boundary receivers and red-zone effectiveness.

  2. 02

    Consistent Contested Catches

    He is consistent in contested-catch situations, high-pointing 50/50 balls and securing them through contact.

  3. 03

    Detailed Route Running

    He exhibits detailed route running for his size, utilizing footwork and tempo control at the top of the stem.

  4. 04

    Alignment Versatility

    He offers alignment versatility with productive reps at X, Z, and in the slot at LSU, understanding landmarks.

  5. 05

    Strong Ball Tracking

    He shows strong ball-tracking and body control with high-point ability, reeling in contested throws inbounds.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Lacks Elite Burner Speed

    Despite 4.4 speed, he is not a true burner, occasionally getting run down and not consistently stacking corners.

  2. 02

    Inconsistent Separation

    Separation against off-man coverage can be inconsistent as patient stems sometimes lack sudden burst for windows.

  3. 03

    Average Twitch Out of Breaks

    He displays average twitch out of breaks, winning more through frame and body control than short-area separation.

  4. 04

    Limited Outside Production

    His 2020 season featured slot-heavy production, leading evaluators to project his outside game from flashes.

08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2018LSU13121920
2019LSU124667113
2020LSU74873110
Career32106159423

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2020
13.0%of team plays
94 percentile at positionLSU
Pass plays · 22.6%Run plays · 0.0%Third down · 14.6%Passing downs · 13.2%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Chris ConleyFA

Realistic: size/speed vertical WR2/3 with contested-catch role

/ Ceiling
Michael ThomasRetired

Ceiling: big-bodied X with route polish, unlikely without the sudden separator gene

/ Floor
Kevin WhiteRetired

Floor: high-testing WR whose route-tree/coaching gaps kept the physical profile from converting

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV
5

Bust. 17 catches as a rookie, cut before Year 3 after another disappointing camp. Signed with Kansas City in 2023 (10 catches), out of the league by 2025. Correct scouting: the frame plays only when the separation catches up. It never did.

Pre-draft context: Three-year LSU contributor who broke through in the 2019 national championship offense (46/671/13) as the third receiver behind Ja'Marr Chase and Justin Jefferson, then led LSU in 2020 with 48/731/10 in seven games before opting out. Measured a rare 6'2 3/8"/205 with 33 1/2" arms and 4.38 pro-day speed — a size/speed profile that graded as top-15 in most 2021 media boards.

Route tree at LSU featured big-slot, backside X and red-zone fade usage rather than full-field X responsibilities, so full-field separation vs press-man was projection more than proof.

Fit with Carolina: Matt Rhule / Joe Brady drafted him at #59 to be the vertical/big-slot piece opposite Robby Anderson and D.J. Moore. Rookie year 17/138/0 in 13 games under a chaotic Sam Darnold/Cam Newton QB room. 2022 dipped to 28/490/1 after Baker Mayfield / Rhule fired. 2023 (14/295/1) ended with a Nov release. Bounced through Raiders/Bills/Chiefs practice squads 2024-25 without carving a role.

Retrospective: A miss where the physical traits never converted — QB churn was real but the route-tree limits pre-draft flagged were exactly what capped him at NFL level.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile