Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #089
WR· Round 3

Nico
Collins.

Nico Collins
Sickos Grade
64.3/100
Pre-draft #89

Michigan official athletic logoMichigan· 6'4"· 215 lb· 4.43s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9378
National · #138HS class · 2017
Clay-Chalkville, AL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R3 · #89 · Houston Texans

"A 6'4" Michigan receiver stuck in a run-heavy offense, with 2019 tape and a 2020 opt-out — a Round-3 boundary X projection where the frame and hands were the argument."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Collins releases with a patient first step, using hand-swipes and shoulder-dips to defeat press coverage. He eats cushion with an easy strider's gait that conceals his speed until late in the route. His primary separator is body positioning on the vertical plane, excelling on back-shoulder fades, over-the-shoulder go routes, and boundary comebacks, where he stacks defenders, tracks the ball early, and finishes with strong late hands.

Underneath, he presents as a large-target hitch and slant runner. He breaks tackles after the catch through sheer mass rather than agility. He lacks true short-area quickness on option routes and tends to round off breaks on comebacks and digs when not technically precise. Physical off-coverage can disrupt his timing.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

West Coast timing offense built around rhythm throws and horizontal passing concepts to set up play-action vertical shots to boundary receivers.

X receiverBoundary WRFade specialistRed zone threat
Best role

Year 1 as a Z or slot receiver who can develop into a starting X receiver and serve as a situational deep threat, especially in the red zone; ceiling is a true boundary alpha receiver.

Wrong fit

Spread RPO offenses that require quick-twitch route running, heavy option routes, and consistent YAC from their outside receivers.

Collins's success hinges on a scheme that prioritizes his contested-catch ability and linear speed, allowing him to thrive as a primary vertical threat rather than a nuanced route technician.

03Film room

Top 50 Plays of Michigan WR Nico Collins

Official Big Ten Network cutup of Collins' Michigan career — boundary fades, back-shoulder wins, and vertical shots that define his pre-draft archetype.

Nico Collins Top Plays of the 2023 Season

Team-produced reel from his All-Pro 2023 breakout with C.J. Stroud — every scheme concept the pre-draft evaluators projected shows up here.

Nico Collins 2023 Highlights | Every Target, Catch, and Run

Full-season target log from 2023: shows route diversity, contested-catch finishing, and yards-per-route-run production against NFL coverage.

04The evaluation

As an X-receiver prospect, Collins offered a team a perimeter threat built to win consistently at the boundary. His 6'4", 215-pound frame, combined with a 4.43 forty-yard dash, provided a compelling blend of size and speed, projecting him as a player who could dominate contested catches and provide a significant vertical presence.

Michigan utilized Collins primarily as a boundary target, where he accumulated 78 catches for 1,388 yards and 13 touchdowns across the 2018-2019 seasons. He opted out of the pandemic-shortened 2020 season. His role consistently featured vertical routes and contested-catch opportunities against Big Ten corners.

Evaluators were divided, with some noting a limited route tree and questions about separation, while others highlighted his elite physical traits and proven contested-catch ability. The consensus projected him in the late second to mid-third round, identifying him as an ascending trait-based selection whose effectiveness would be closely tied to quarterback play.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    True X-receiver body type

    At 6'4"/215 with 4.43 speed and long arms, he wins vertically and secures throws over shorter corners.

  2. 02

    Natural ball-tracking ability

    He adjusts to back-shoulder and boundary fades, finishing through contact with strong late hands.

  3. 03

    Vertical acceleration

    His fluid strider's gait allows him to close distance quickly and uncover late against corners.

  4. 04

    Effective boundary release

    Uses a patient first step, hand-swipes, and shoulder dips to defeat single-jam techniques.

  5. 05

    Proven red-zone threat

    Targeted as a boundary fade and back-shoulder specialist, scoring 13 touchdowns on 78 college catches.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Narrow college route tree

    Primarily ran go routes, comebacks, hitches, and fades, limiting exposure to a full NFL route repertoire.

  2. 02

    Limited separation creation

    Seldom created clean separation at the top of intermediate routes against man coverage.

  3. 03

    Inconsistent footwork

    Showed drifting shoulders on intermediate route breaks, allowing defensive backs to close quickly.

  4. 04

    Inconsistent against top defenses

    Did not produce dominant stat lines against top Big Ten defenses like Ohio State and Penn State.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'4"
Weight
215 lb
40 yd
4.43s
Vertical
37.5"
Broad
10'5"
3-cone
6.78s
Shuttle
4.29s
Bench
14
06Athletic profilevs. WR on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.43sp50
Vertical
37.5inp50
Broad jump
125inp50
Three-cone
6.78sp50
Shuttle
4.29sp50
Bench
14repp50
08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2017Michigan93270
2018Michigan13386326
2019Michigan13377297
Career3578138813

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2019
7.1%of team plays
71 percentile at positionMichigan
Pass plays · 14.6%Run plays · 0.0%Third down · 8.5%Passing downs · 7.1%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts

Reliable outside-the-numbers WR1/WR2 with contested-catch craft, red-zone value, and quarterback-dependent production — the exact archetype scouts saw at the pick.

/ Ceiling
Mike EvansTampa Bay Buccaneers

Best-case boundary X outcome: big-framed vertical threat who wins on back-shoulder and contested throws, elevates a rhythm-passer offense, and hits 1,000 yards on volume rather than separation.

/ Floor
Kenny GolladayDetroit Lions

Downside path: same length-and-track-it archetype whose value evaporates without competent quarterback play, and whose separation profile keeps him from carrying a passing game on his own.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
2
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV
32

Massive steal. Rotational Years 1-2, breakout Year 3 (80-1,297-8, Pro Bowl alt), full-time WR1 by Year 4 (68-1,000+ with C.J. Stroud). Signed 3-year, $72.75M extension in 2024. One of the top Round-3 WR values of the last decade.

**Pre-draft context.** Collins arrived in Ann Arbor as a top-100 recruit out of Birmingham (Alabama) and grew into Michigan's boundary X across 2018–2019, producing 78 receptions for 1,388 yards and 13 touchdowns opposite Donovan Peoples-Jones and Ronnie Bell. His 2020 opt-out during the pandemic-shortened Big Ten season shrank his workload sample but did not touch his physical profile: 6'4", 215 pounds, verified 4.43 speed, and rare boundary length. Analysts pushed the athletic bet — track-and-jump-ball body type, boundary vertical hits, and contested-catch tape against Big Ten corners — while pointing to a thin route tree, uneven quarterback play at Michigan, and a limited separation profile. Consensus landed him in the late Day-2 range as a trait-and-frame bet.

**NFL fit — Houston Texans.** Houston selected Collins at 89th overall to reset a receiver room in transition and give the offense a legitimate boundary alpha. His first two seasons were noisy: 33 catches for 446 yards as a rookie in a fractured offense, then 37 for 481 in 2022 across an injury-affected year. Everything changed when C.J. Stroud arrived in 2023. The offensive scheme weaponized Collins on the outside with vertical shots, back-shoulder fades, and dig routes off play-action, and Collins exploded for 80 receptions, 1,297 yards and 8 touchdowns, earning second-team All-Pro and Pro Bowl honors. He backed it up in 2024 with 68-1,268-7 despite missing time with a hamstring injury, pacing the league in yards-per-route-run stretches whenever healthy.

**Retrospective.** In April 2024 the Texans made him a foundation piece with a three-year, $72.75 million extension, cementing his place as Stroud's WR1. Collins is now one of the clearest hits of the entire 2021 class and, in hindsight, a top-shelf value at pick 89 — a scheme-and-quarterback story as much as a scouting story. The pre-draft profile (frame, length, contested-catch, vertical wins) translated exactly as the trait bettors said it would once he was paired with rhythm quarterback play and an offense willing to build outside-the-numbers concepts around his skill set. The evaluators who talked themselves off him because of the college route tree and Michigan quarterback situation have publicly owned the miss.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile