Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #022
QB· Round 1

Mac
Jones.

Mac Jones
Sickos Grade
79.9/100
Pre-draft #22

Alabama official athletic logoAlabama· 6'2"· 217 lb· 4.72s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★☆☆stars.8847
National · #391HS class · 2017
The Bolles School, FL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R1 · #15 · New England Patriots

"Pre-snap processing, anticipation and ball placement all grade among the top three in the class. The traits he lacks grade in the opposite direction, at the same tier."Pre-draft read

01Play style

He operates as a timing and rhythm passer from within the pocket. He relies on pre-snap processing, precise footwork, and anticipation to deliver throws on three-step and five-step drops. He accurately places the ball into tight windows over the middle on dig, seam, and sit routes, and can execute perimeter timing routes when he has trust in his protection.

When the pocket collapses or his initial read is covered, his mechanics tend to falter. Off-platform throws and pump-and-tuck movements are not characteristic of his play. He presents no running threat, averaging 14 rushing yards per game in college. His effectiveness is dependent on scheme and a clean pocket.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

West Coast timing system, featuring play-action, full-field reads, and a strong running game to set up downfield shots and take pressure off the quarterback.

Pure pocket passerRhythm throwerImmediate starter
Best role

Immediate starter in a timing-based play-action scheme, with the ceiling of a top-10 franchise quarterback who wins with anticipation and accuracy rather than athleticism.

Wrong fit

Spread-to-run or RPO-heavy systems that rely on quarterback mobility and off-script playmaking.

His high-end processing and accuracy make him a great fit for a traditional pocket-passing scheme, but his lack of mobility severely limits his potential in modern, improvisational offenses.

03Film room

Mac Jones For Heisman VHS Highlights 2020

Mac Jones Pro Day HIGHLIGHTS! PINPOINT passes

Why some believe Mac Jones is the best QB in the 2021 NFL Draft class | Get Up

04The evaluation

He projects as a classic pocket-passing quarterback, valuable to a team seeking a technically refined distribution specialist. His elite accuracy, evidenced by a 77.4% completion rate in his final college season, is his defining trait, mitigating concerns about his limited mobility. Teams buying into him acquire a quarterback who processes quickly and delivers the ball with precision.

In his sole season as a starter in 2020, he led Alabama to a national championship. He played in an NFL-style offense often supported by a highly talented cast including five future first or second-round draft picks. His usage frequently involved targets to receivers who generated separation on a high percentage of plays, allowing him to operate within structure.

Evaluators noted his functional but not elite arm strength and a sharp decline in accuracy when forced off-platform, largely due to his limited mobility, measured at a 4.87 forty-yard dash. The consensus viewed him as a first-round prospect, with the New England Patriots selecting him 15th overall, a decision that surprised some given other quarterbacks available.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Elite accuracy

    Achieved a 77.4% completion rate in 2020, mitigating concerns about his limited mobility.

  2. 02

    High production

    Recorded 4,500 yards and 41 TDs in his 2020 national championship season.

  3. 03

    Timing and anticipation

    Consistently led receivers on slants, digs, and comebacks within scheme concepts.

  4. 04

    Pro-style offense experience

    Played in an NFL-style offense under Steve Sarkisian at Alabama.

  5. 05

    High football IQ

    Shows plus pre-snap diagnosis and understanding of route concepts.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Limited mobility

    A 4.87 forty-yard dash means designed movement plays are not part of his game.

  2. 02

    Functional arm strength

    Arm strength is not elite, requiring consistently elite accuracy to compensate.

  3. 03

    Poor off-platform accuracy

    Ball trajectory and placement suffer when forced out of a clean pocket.

  4. 04

    Talent-supported production

    His 2020 success was aided by a talented Alabama supporting cast.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'2"
Weight
217 lb
40 yd
4.72s
Vertical
32"
Broad
9'8"
3-cone
7.04s
Shuttle
4.39s
06Athletic profilevs. QB on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.72sp50
Vertical
32inp50
Broad jump
116inp50
Three-cone
7.04sp50
Shuttle
4.39sp50
Bench
rep
08College production
YrTeamGCmpAttYdsTDInt
2018Alabama1451312310
2019Alabama12971411503143
2020Alabama133114024500414
Career394135566126567

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2020
48.8%of team plays
74 percentile at positionAlabama
Pass plays · 93.7%Run plays · 5.3%Third down · 64.1%Passing downs · 59.9%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Chad PenningtonNew York Jets

Smart, accurate distributor with strong command and a ceiling tied more to precision than physical dominance.

/ Ceiling
Kirk CousinsMinnesota Vikings

Timing-and-accuracy starter who can produce high-end efficiency when the protection and route structure stay on schedule.

/ Floor
Brian HoyerNew England Patriots

If the arm and creation limits show up too often, he becomes a quality spot starter rather than a franchise answer.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
1
All-Pro
0
Seasons
4
Career AV
20

2021 (rookie, NE): 22-13 TD-INT, 67.6% completions, 3,801 yds — Pro Bowl alternate, playoffs (wild-card loss vs. BUF), All-Rookie honorable. Best year of his career. 2022 (NE): OC vacant after McDaniels' departure; Patricia as play-caller — offensive collapse, 14-11 TD-INT in 14 games, sub-60 PFF grade. 2023 (NE): 10-12 TD-INT, benched in Week 15 for Bailey Zappe. March 2024: traded to JAX for a conditional 6th. 2024 (JAX): Trevor Lawrence's backup, 4 starts when Lawrence went down in Week 13 — 3-8 TD-INT, sub-NFL-caliber floor. 2025 (JAX): backup / QB2 with 2 spot starts when Lawrence has been out. Career_av: 20.

Mac Jones is the most divisive evaluation of the 2021 class because the traits he has are elite and the traits he lacks are elite in the opposite direction. Pre-snap processing, anticipation and ball placement — the three pillars of the rhythm QB — grade among the top three in the class, with Justin Fields, Trey Lance and Zach Wilson below him. His 2020 Alabama season is one of the most complete statistical seasons of the century: 41-4 TD-INT, 77.4% completions (SEC record), 4,500 yards, 203.1 passer rating (FBS record). He won the Davey O'Brien, Manning, Unitas, finished Heisman runner-up and won the national title dismantling Ohio State. The over-the-middle throws vs. Georgia (an anticipatory dig into the Cover-2 window to Smith), the back-shoulder to Waddle vs. Notre Dame and the pre-snap safety manipulations vs. Auburn all show a QB with NFL-Day-1 processing.

The bear case is equally emphatic. The 2020 Alabama roster had five eventual first/second-rounders (Smith, Waddle, Harris, Dickerson, Leatherwood), and the offensive scheme generated separation on roughly 80% of plays. Zero athletic threat: 4.87 forty, 14 rush yds per game, doesn't extend. Mid-tier NFL arm that doesn't force open windows with velocity — depends on anticipation, and when the anticipation misses there's no recovery.

The likely comp was always Chad Pennington: rhythm QB with elite processing and physical limits who produced two Comeback Player of the Year awards and a solid career before his shoulders wrecked him. The high is Kirk Cousins — same in-pocket precision-passer profile that earned $200M+ in the NFL. The low is Brian Hoyer: the version where the right environment never appears. The post-draft arc was almost exactly rookie-Cousins followed by environmental collapse: 2021 with an offensive play-caller focused on rhythm passing — 22-13 TD-INT, 67.6% completions, Pro Bowl alternate, playoffs. Then that play-caller departed, and NE placed him under an interim offensive play-caller in 2022 — a catastrophic decision that froze his development. 2023 with a new offensive play-caller didn't recover the rhythm. Traded to Jacksonville in March 2024 as Trevor Lawrence's backup; won the role and in 2025 has taken partial starts when Lawrence has been out. He's on his third contract as a quality backup, not as a franchise QB. The talent was real; the post-2021 environment buried it.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile