Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #042
T· Round 2

Liam
Eichenberg.

Liam Eichenberg
Sickos Grade
71.9/100
Pre-draft #42

Notre Dame official athletic logoNotre Dame· 6'6"· 306 lb

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9613
National · #79HS class · 2016
St. Ignatius, OH
247Sports composite via CFBD
R2 · #42 · Miami Dolphins

"A three-year Notre Dame left tackle whose technique was NFL-ready and whose 33 1/2" arms and average kick-slide had NFL evaluators penciling him inside at the next level."Pre-draft read

01Play style

This offensive lineman plays with technique over traits. In pass protection, he employs a compact two-hand punch, a controlled kick slide, and maintains a clean base, rarely being knocked off his feet or beaten by familiar schemes. He consistently mirrors rushers and demonstrates patient hand timing, avoiding oversetting or opening gaps.

In the run game, he is a positional blocker who excels in down-blocks, gap/power combinations, and short-pull assignments where leverage and angles are crucial. He is technically sound in various run schemes, effectively sealing the backside on outside zone plays and communicating combo blocks to the second level.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

This offensive lineman is best suited for a gap/duo power run game scheme that prioritizes a strong interior and can accommodate a right tackle with excellent technique and intelligence.

Right TackleBlocking GuardSwing Tackle
Best role

Year 1 as a starting right tackle or high-end guard, with a ceiling as a long-term starter at either position in a power running attack.

Wrong fit

A wide zone based scheme that asks tackles to consistently reach and cutoff 3-techniques or mirror twitchy speed rushers over a wide arc would highlight his athletic limitations.

Eichenberg's high football IQ and refined technique allow him to excel in schemes that value precise, assignment-based blocking over pure athleticism.

03Film room

Notre Dame LT Liam Eichenberg — Career Highlights

Career reel from Notre Dame — pass sets, down-blocks and short pulls that defined his LT tape.

Liam Eichenberg — NFL Draft Tape (Notre Dame OL)

Cut-up of full pass-pro and run reps used by scouts during the 2021 evaluation cycle.

2021 NFL Draft Profile: Notre Dame OL Liam Eichenberg

Pre-draft scouting breakdown covering strengths, weaknesses and projected NFL role.

04The evaluation

Liam Eichenberg projects as a polished blocker and versatile lineman, offering teams immediate contributions. His robust four-year tenure and three-year starting experience at left tackle for a program known for producing NFL offensive linemen underscore his reliability. Evaluators saw him as a safe second-round tackle with a floor as a day-one guard, largely due to his consistent production and esteemed pedigree.

He anchored an offensive line that won the Joe Moore Award in 2020, earning first-team All-ACC and consensus All-America honors, showcasing his impact and leadership. His college usage included extensive reps at left tackle, where he consistently faced high-level competition, validating his on-field performance against challenging opponents.

Despite his achievements, concerns centered on his marginal length and athletic profile for a left tackle at the professional level, with 33 1/4 inch arms noted as a potential limitation. This led to a consensus view that he might be best suited for right tackle or guard, as his tape flagged a habit of oversetting against speed rushers on the edge. He was ultimately selected in the second round, 42nd overall.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Pass protection technique

    He employs a compact two-hand punch, a controlled kick slide, and maintains a clean base, rarely being knocked off his feet or beaten.

  2. 02

    Positional run blocker

    He is a positional blocker who excels in down-blocks, gap/power combinations, and short-pull assignments where leverage and angles are crucial.

  3. 03

    Technically sound run game

    He is technically sound in various run schemes, effectively sealing the backside on outside zone plays and communicating combo blocks.

  4. 04

    Reliable on-field performance

    His robust four-year tenure and three-year starting experience at left tackle for a program known for producing NFL offensive linemen underscore his reliability.

  5. 05

    College accolades received

    He anchored an offensive line that won the Joe Moore Award in 2020, earning first-team All-ACC and consensus All-America honors.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Marginal arm length

    Concerns centered on his marginal length, with 33 1/4 inch arms noted as a potential limitation for a left tackle at the professional level.

  2. 02

    Average athletic profile

    His athletic profile for a left tackle at the professional level raised concerns, especially regarding quickness.

  3. 03

    Oversetting against speed

    His tape flagged a habit of oversetting against speed rushers on the edge, which can create open gaps against quick defenders.

  4. 04

    Best suited for other roles

    He might be best suited for right tackle or guard, as his tape flagged a habit of oversetting against speed rushers.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'6"
Weight
306 lb
Vertical
26.5"
Broad
8'9"
3-cone
7.53s
Shuttle
4.58s
Bench
33
06Athletic profilevs. T on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
s
Vertical
26.5inp50
Broad jump
105inp50
Three-cone
7.53sp50
Shuttle
4.58sp50
Bench
33repp50
08College production
YrTeamG
2017Notre Dame1
2018Notre Dame13
2019Notre Dame13
2020Notre Dame12
Career39

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Halapoulivaati VaitaiFA

Realistic outcome: swing backup who starts when injuries hit, wins with know-how, gets exposed when asked to be a full-time protector.

/ Ceiling
Joe ThuneyCHI

Ceiling as a technician interior starter who slides between guard and tackle in an emergency and hides tools with plan and hands.

/ Floor
Isaiah WynnFA

Floor: pedigree first-day pick who never locks down one spot, bounces between LG/RT and washes out of a starting job by year four.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV
10

Below expectations. Started 14 games at RT as a rookie (below-average), moved to LG in 2022 (average), out of the starting lineup 2023 with an oblique injury and lost the job. Traded to the Browns in 2024 as depth. Solid backup / spot-starter career, not the multi-year starter Miami projected.

**Pre-draft context.** Liam Eichenberg came out of Notre Dame as one of the safest, most polished blockers in the 2021 class: 6'6", 302 pounds with 33 1/4" arms, a four-year contributor and three-year starter at left tackle for a program that produced Ronnie Stanley, Zack Martin, Mike McGlinchey and Quenton Nelson before him. He anchored the 2020 line that won the Joe Moore Award as the nation's best O-line, earning first-team All-ACC and consensus All-America honors. The board consensus had him as a second-round tackle with a Day 1 floor at guard — production and pedigree were bankable, but the tape flagged a marginal length/athletic profile for left tackle and a habit of oversetting versus speed on the edge.

**NFL fit — Miami Dolphins.** Miami took him 42nd overall as a plug-and-play piece for a young Tua Tagovailoa, and immediately moved him around the line: left guard, right tackle and center reps as a rookie in 2021, all five positions on the resume by year two. The versatility that scouts liked in college became a survival mechanism in the pros — every time the Dolphins tried to lock him in at one spot, injury or scheme change bounced him back. He started 15 games at left guard in 2022, but an outside-zone system exposed his lateral range, and by 2023–2024 he was a swing interior backup rather than a starter. Miami declined his fifth-year option in May 2024, and he played out 2024 as a rotational piece before hitting free agency.

**Retrospective.** Eichenberg is the archetypal "safe college tackle who has to kick inside and still isn't a clean fit anywhere." The pre-draft flag was accurate: he was never long or twitchy enough to survive on an NFL edge, and the interior move demanded quicker feet and heavier hands than his frame offered. He became a useful depth piece — a starter's résumé in emergencies, seven positions of experience, no true position — but not the mid-round hit the pedigree implied. A functional pro career that reads more like a good backup than a second-round return.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile