Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #077
WR· Round 3

Josh
Palmer.

JP
Sickos Grade
63.5/100
Pre-draft #77

Tennessee official athletic logoTennessee

/ Recruiting profile
★★★☆☆stars.8552
National · #1259HS class · 2023
Autauga Academy, AL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R3 · #77 · Los Angeles Chargers

"A Tennessee WR stuck on bad offenses whose contested-catch tape and physical frame profiled as a Round 3-4 WR3 with contested-target upside."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Palmer aligns as an outside receiver, utilizing hand usage, tempo changes, and stacking against defensive backs to create separation against press coverage. He wins through pacing, leverage, and route craft, rather than raw explosiveness. He maintains body control on back-shoulder throws and consistently wins through contact at the top of intermediate routes. He is effective at finishing contested catches.

His role projects as an X/Z possession receiver running a full route tree including the glance, comeback, dig, fade, and deep over. He contributes as a willing and effective blocker in the run game, which helps keep him on the field in multi-receiver sets. He consistently secures contested throws when the quarterback delivers the ball into tight windows.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

West Coast timing system, featuring complex route trees and an emphasis on possession receivers who can win with intelligence and precise technique vs. raw athleticism.

Boundary XZ-receiverFlanker
Best role

Year 1 role as a strong WR4 with special teams value, ascending to a reliable WR3 as a technician who can run a diverse route tree from outside alignments.

Wrong fit

An Air Raid or spread RPO system that relies on explosive YAC receivers and deep threats, as his average speed and limited twitch would be exposed.

Palmer projects best as a versatile possession receiver in a nuanced passing attack where his route running, contested catch ability, and blocking can shine.

03Film room

Tennessee WR Josh Palmer Highlights

Tennessee four-year cut-up — body-adjust catches on the boundary, back-shoulder wins and press-beat releases against SEC corners.

Keenan Allen Teaching Joshua Palmer

Rookie-year Chargers development piece — Palmer inheriting the Keenan Allen route-tree apprenticeship at the pre-2022 promotion moment.

Josh Palmer with the game-changing catch for the Bills vs Ravens

2025 Bills-era signature play — game-changing catch on the game-winning drive vs Baltimore, validating the WR2/3 second-contract role.

04The evaluation

Palmer is evaluated as a professional route-runner with projectable receiving traits for the X-receiver role. Despite college statistics that did not reflect high volume, his advanced technical skills and ability to win against press coverage confirmed a solid floor for a long-term WR3/WR4. His performance at the Senior Bowl was critical in validating these traits against NFL-caliber defensive backs.

He was a four-year starter at Tennessee, where he remained through multiple coaching and quarterback changes. His college production never eclipsed 500 receiving yards in a season, largely due to a run-first offense that struggled with consistent quarterback play. He was primarily deployed as an outside receiver, tasked with running a diverse route tree in a scheme that did not consistently feature the passing game.

Concerns centered on his limited collegiate production and the absence of explosive YAC ability. However, his strong showing against top competition at the Senior Bowl underscored the potential for his route craft and reliable hands to translate. He was a consensus Day 2 prospect, and the Los Angeles Chargers selected him in the third round, 77th overall, recognizing his potential as a boundary complement.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Elite Release Package

    Elite Release Package — Hand usage, tempo changes, and stacking against defensive backs beat press coverage consistently from outside alignments.

  2. 02

    Contested Catch Profile

    Contested Catch Profile — Maintains body control and consistently wins through contact at the top of intermediate routes and back-shoulder throws.

  3. 03

    Route Tree Diversity

    Route Tree Diversity — Runs a full route tree including glance, comeback, dig, fade, and deep over with detailed execution.

  4. 04

    High Football IQ

    High Football IQ — Remained a four-year starter through multiple coaching and quarterback changes at Tennessee, demonstrating reliability.

  5. 05

    Effective Blocker

    Effective Blocker — Contributes as a willing and effective blocker in the run game, helping to stay on the field in multi-receiver sets.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Limited College Production

    Limited College Production — Never eclipsed 500 receiving yards in a season, largely due to a run-first offense and inconsistent quarterback play.

  2. 02

    Zone Separation

    Zone Separation — Wins through pacing, leverage, and route craft, rather than raw explosiveness against defensive backs in zone coverage.

  3. 03

    Lack of YAC Ability

    Lack of YAC Ability — Does not possess explosive YAC ability, lacking the twitch and long speed to turn short catches into sustained gains.

  4. 04

    Average Vertical Speed

    Average Vertical Speed — Wins deep balls with body position and back-shoulder timing, not by running away from opposing cornerbacks.

08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2017Tennessee129980
2018Tennessee12234842
2019Tennessee13344571
2020Tennessee10334754
Career479915147

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2020
9.1%of team plays
82 percentile at positionTennessee
Pass plays · 19.2%Run plays · 0.0%Third down · 9.8%Passing downs · 12.6%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Nelson AgholorBAL

Realistic: reliable multi-team outside WR3 who cashed multiple free-agent deals off release craft and vertical timing without ever hitting a true breakout year — the outcome Palmer has hit.

/ Ceiling
Michael GallupFA

Ceiling: technical outside WR who parlayed release craft and contested-catch ability into a 1,000-yard season and a top-of-market WR2 contract — the peak outcome for the possession-first archetype.

/ Floor
Chris ConleyFA

Floor: rotational deep-threat WR who never established a consistent starter role and bounced across three teams as a WR4 — the outcome if the 2022 Chargers spike had never happened.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV
18

Round-3 hit. WR4 rookie season, breakout 2022 (72/769/3 as de facto WR2), steady WR3 production 2023-2024 (~40 catches / ~580 yards each) in offenses that never fully leaned on him. Signed with Buffalo in 2025 free agency as a starting outside WR next to Shakir and Coleman. Reliable multi-year contributor, exactly the "cash-twice" WR3 outcome projected — never a Pro Bowler, but a paid, entrenched rotation piece at a premium position.

Four-year Tennessee starter who never once eclipsed 500 receiving yards in a college season — a red flag on the surface, but every scout who dug in framed it as an offense/QB story rather than a talent story. Palmer arrived at Knoxville as a top-100 recruit and stayed through multiple coaching changes, seven quarterbacks, and two full scheme resets, quietly posting 34/106/33 catches across his final three years while playing outside receiver in a run-first offense that couldn't consistently threaten defenses.

Pre-draft: 6'1", 210 lb, 4.51 pro-day forty, standout Senior Bowl week where he separated cleanly against Day-2 corners and confirmed the release-package and hands upside on film. The Chargers selected him at 77 as a boundary complement to Keenan Allen and Mike Williams. Rookie 2021: 33/353/4 in a limited target share.

2022 was the breakout — with Mike Williams and Allen missing significant time, Palmer stepped into de facto WR2 duty and finished 72/769/3, top-30 WR in yards, and one of the season's best mid-round-value bumps league-wide. 2023 regressed to 38/581/2 as the receiver room stayed intact and target share compressed. 2024: 39/584/1 in a run-first offense — quiet counting stats masked a clean 15.0-yards-per-catch mark and one of his best deep-ball years on tape. Free agent in 2025: signed a multi-year deal with the Buffalo Bills as a starting outside piece next to Khalil Shakir and Keon Coleman in Josh Allen's offense.

2025 with Buffalo: 22/303/0 through 12 games in a distributed target tree. Overall arc: exactly the "reliable outside WR3 who cashes twice" outcome scouts projected — a Round-3 hit at a premium position, if not a splash one.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile