Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021R5 · #164
S· Round 5

Jamar
Johnson.

Jamar Johnson
Sickos Grade
47.3/100

Indiana official athletic logoIndiana· 6'2"· 205 lb· 4.58s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★☆☆stars.8477
National · #1130HS class · 2018
Riverview, FL
247Sports composite via CFBD
R5 · #164 · DEN

"A 6-2, 205 Indiana single-high safety with four picks in eight 2020 games and rare closing burst on the ball — a Round-5 Cover-1/Cover-3 free safety projection whose 4.58 forty and stiff hips capped the range profile."Pre-draft read

01Play style

Plays as a versatile safety, rotating between deep half, low hole, and blitzing nickel in sub-packages. Primary trait is anticipation, reading the quarterback's eyes from depth to break downhill and attack the receiver's near hip at the catch point, which generates interceptions and pass breakups. Possesses natural hands and body control tracking the ball over his shoulder.

Tackling is willing and physical in the alley, showing a violent uphill trigger against tight end drags and screens. While effective in man coverage on backs and short-area zones, he struggles when asked to open and run out of the middle of the field due to hip tightness, and his change-of-direction limits mirror matches. The athletic ceiling restricts recovery speed.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

Fangio two-high defense, focused on matching routes out of Cover-4 and Cover-6 concepts, with zone-match principles allowing safeties to rob underneath routes and rotate deep.

Free SafetyStrong SafetyDimebackerNickel Blitz
Best role

Year 1 contributor as a rotational safety and sub-package specialist, with the ceiling to develop into a starting split-safety who creates turnovers.

Wrong fit

A dedicated single-high scheme where he is consistently asked to cover ground sideline-to-sideline without the benefit of a running mate or short-post help.

Johnson's anticipation and ball production align perfectly with a two-high system that values opportunistic safeties, but his athletic limitations will be exposed in schemes demanding elite recovery speed and change-of-direction.

03Film room

Elite Indiana Safety Jamar Johnson HD

Full 2020 Indiana highlight reel showing ball production, deep-half range and downhill trigger.

Jamar Johnson Ultimate Indiana Highlights

Career cutup covering split-safety reps, TE matchup coverage and ball skills.

2021 NFL Draft Preview: Indiana's Jamar Johnson

Pre-draft BTN feature previewing his projection as a rangy Big Ten free safety.

04The evaluation

Jamar Johnson projects as a depth safety with potential for sub-package roles, ideally deployed in schemes that value anticipation and ball production over elite recovery speed. His ability to read quarterbacks and impact passing lanes from multiple alignments provides a clear path to contributing, particularly as a robber or deep half defender. The primary trade-off is athletic limitations in open space.

Johnson was a two-year contributor who had a breakout season in 2020 at Indiana, recording four interceptions and five pass breakups in eight games. He rotated between various safety roles, demonstrating versatility in a Big Ten defense, earning second-team All-Big Ten honors. This production, combined with his frame, positioned him as a valued commodity despite limited career starts.

Concerns about his athletic profile, specifically a 4.58 forty-yard dash and 7.22 three-cone drill, emerged during the draft process, pushing his consensus projection from mid-Day 2 to the fourth or fifth round. Denver selected him at pick 164 in the fifth round, betting on his instincts and ball skills to outweigh the athletic flags.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Anticipation

    Reads the quarterback's eyes from Cover-2 and Cover-4 depth and triggers before the throw arrives, which compressed windows into interceptable throws on Big Ten tape.

  2. 02

    Ball production

    Four interceptions and five pass breakups in eight 2020 games with a clean tracking radius and hands that finish above the frame at the high point.

  3. 03

    Frame

    Legitimate 6-2, 205 with 32-inch arms and enough mass to match up on TE-Y in dime, an ideal single-high build for match-quarters or Fangio-tree deep-third rules.

  4. 04

    Physicality

    Willing downhill tackler in the alley, will fit off climb blocks against zone runs and delivers thump on curl/flat throws to the near shoulder.

  5. 05

    Versatility

    Rotated between deep half, low hole, dime linebacker and nickel blitz at Indiana, giving a coordinator multiple sub-package roles from day one rather than a one-hat safety.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Athletic ceiling

    4.58 forty, 35-inch vertical and a 5.86 RAS put the recovery/range profile below what a true single-high center-fielder needs against NFL post/corner concepts.

  2. 02

    Hip fluidity

    7.22 three-cone and 4.41 shuttle show up on tape when asked to open, redirect and carry vertical stems out of the middle of the field.

  3. 03

    Sample size

    Only 20 career starts at Indiana with one true breakout season, which raises the question of whether the 2020 ball production repeats against NFL quarterbacks.

  4. 04

    Long speed

    Struggles to close vertical seams once the receiver has stacked his leverage, a boundary safety carrying a TE-Y or vertical slot needed help from underneath.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'2"
Weight
205 lb
40 yd
4.58s
Vertical
35"
Broad
10'2"
3-cone
7.22s
Shuttle
4.41s
Bench
17
Relative Athletic Score
5.86
/10 · official

Relative Athletic Score (Kent Lee Platte) benchmarks combine/pro-day numbers against every measured prospect at the position since 1987. 10.00 is elite; 5.00 is average.

06Athletic profilevs. S on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.58sp50
Vertical
35inp50
Broad jump
122inp50
Three-cone
7.22sp50
Shuttle
4.41sp50
Bench
17repp50
08College production
YrTeamGTklSkIntPDFF
2018Indiana1020110
2019Indiana13253200
2020Indiana8421440
Career31694750

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Marcus WilliamsNO

Trigger-and-attack free safety with hands and instincts, though a tier below Williams' short-area quickness. This was the Day-2 template scouts wrote pre-combine.

/ Ceiling
Justin SimmonsDEN

Best-case: a rangy pattern-match single-high with elite anticipation, though Simmons was a plus-mover and Johnson never matched the recovery athleticism.

/ Floor
Terrell EdmundsPIT

Downside outcome: a big-frame safety who ends up better in the box than as a true field-side rotator. Roster longevity would've required special-teams equity that never materialized.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV

Bust. Rotational Year 1 (special teams), cut before Year 2. Signed with the Jets and Rams on futures deals, out of the league by 2023.

Pre-draft context. Johnson was a two-year contributor at Indiana who blossomed as a redshirt sophomore in Tom Allen's 2020 defense, playing a hybrid two-high/robber role next to Jaylin Williams and finishing with four INTs, five PBUs, a forced fumble and 34 tackles in eight games. His measurables (6-2, 205, 32-inch arms) were prototype free-safety size, but the athletic testing back-slid from expectations — 4.58 forty, 35-inch vertical, 7.22 three-cone and a 5.86 RAS made the range/recovery profile league-average rather than the plus-athlete boards had projected.

NFL fit — Denver Broncos. Denver picked him at #164 in Round 5 as a developmental deep-third piece behind Justin Simmons and Kareem Jackson under a Fangio-style single-high match structure. The fit made sense in theory — Fangio's defense values quarters processors and disguise safeties over pure rangers — but Johnson never carved out a defined role, playing 34 defensive snaps as a rookie and getting released at final cuts before the 2022 season.

Retrospective. His pro career stalled after Denver: practice-squad stops in Baltimore and Miami through 2022, no active-roster action, and out of the NFL by 2023. The Indiana tape aged well — the ball-hawking, disguise fluency and physicality still show up on cutups — but the athletic gap and lack of special-teams volume were what he could never close. A miss for the Broncos, though a defensible Day-3 swing on production and frame.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile