Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #011
WR· Round 1

Devonta
Smith.

DeVonta Smith
Sickos Grade
81.9/100
Pre-draft #11

Alabama official athletic logoAlabama

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9114
National · #250HS class · 2021
La Salle, OH
247Sports composite via CFBD
R1 · #10 · Philadelphia Eagles

"The first wide receiver to win the Heisman since 1991. The tape is a route-running clinic; the frame is the only reason he isn't a top-five pick."Pre-draft read

01Play style

This outside receiver's game relies on separation, timing, and hands more than physical dominance. He consistently wins with refined release packages, sudden movements in his stems, and highly reliable hands. He prioritizes guaranteed separation at every level of the field and consistently secures the ball, rather than excelling as a tackle-breaking YAC receiver or contested-catch specialist.

He effectively sells vertical routes with intricate head and shoulder movements, demonstrating sudden hip sink at the top of comebacks and digs to create late separation. He processes coverage rotation post-snap, adjusting stem angles to find open areas. He routinely catches the ball away from his body, extending his arms to secure it. His quick release against press coverage neutralizes defenders.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

A modern spread or Air Raid offense focused on timing over physicality.

Boundary WRSlot WRZ receiver
Best role

A starting Z or boundary receiver with potential to develop into a high-volume target on all three levels.

Wrong fit

A traditional run-first West Coast offense that frequently expects receivers to block linebackers or safeties.

DeVonta Smith excels in schemes that prioritize separation, precise route-running, and high-volume targets, making him an immediate impact player despite frame concerns.

03Film room

DeVonta Smith — 2020 Heisman season highlights

The Heisman reel. Best for seeing the FBS-record 23-TD season: route detail on the comebacks and digs, contested-catch tape vs Auburn and Ole Miss, and the CFP semifinal vs Notre Dame (7-130-3).

Every DeVonta Smith TD for Alabama in 2020

Full cut-up of all 23 touchdowns. Best for evaluating red-zone route mastery, release-phase technique vs press, and the hands (three drops on 240 targets) that separate him from every WR in the class.

DeVonta Smith — full scouting report with fits

Full scouting-report treatment with All-22 cut-ups. Best for the technical vocabulary of the route tree — stem angles, hip drop, and separation at the top of the route — and the frame-vs-technique evaluation debate.

04The evaluation

DeVonta Smith projects as a primary outside receiver due to his strong route-running foundation and hand skills, positioning him as a high-volume target from his initial professional season. His game focuses on consistently creating separation and catching the ball, not on physically overpowering defenders. Weighing 170 pounds, he is seen as a scheme-ready, high-IQ pass-catcher prepared to contribute immediately.

At Alabama, Smith was a consistently targeted and dominant receiver, culminating in an FBS-record 23 receiving touchdowns during his senior year. He was utilized across the formation and maintained high production against elite competition, showcasing an advanced understanding of football and the ability to adapt routes post-snap. He sustained a clean bill of health throughout his collegiate career.

The primary evaluative concern for Smith is his slight build, which raised durability questions regarding his ability to withstand NFL physicality. While his technique compensated for this in college, evaluators pondered his frame's resilience at the professional level. Despite these concerns, his production and technical proficiency solidified his position as a consensus top-half-first-round prospect, leading to his selection by the Philadelphia Eagles with the 10th overall pick.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Refined Release Packages

    He consistently wins with refined release packages, demonstrating sudden movements in his stems.

  2. 02

    Highly Reliable Hands

    He effectively catches the ball away from his body, extending his arms to secure the ball.

  3. 03

    Processes Coverage Rotation

    He effectively processes coverage rotation post-snap, adjusting stem angles to find open areas.

  4. 04

    Sells Vertical Routes Well

    He effectively sells vertical routes with intricate head and shoulder movements.

  5. 05

    Clean Bill of Health

    He sustained a clean bill of health throughout his collegiate career at Alabama.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Slight Build Concerns

    His slight build at 170 pounds raised durability questions regarding NFL physicality.

  2. 02

    Functional Strength Lacking

    His below-average functional strength may limit his effectiveness against strong press coverage.

  3. 03

    YAC Production Limited

    His YAC production primarily relies on open space and scheme, not breaking tackles.

  4. 04

    Blocking Projection Limited

    His frame suggests he will be overmatched against NFL safeties and corners as a blocker.

08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2017Alabama1481603
2018Alabama15426936
2019Alabama1368125614
2020Alabama13117185623
Career55235396546

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2020
16.5%of team plays
98 percentile at positionAlabama
Pass plays · 32.6%Run plays · 0.9%Third down · 17.9%Passing downs · 20.8%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
DeSean JacksonPHI/WAS/TB

Undersized but technically brilliant WR who becomes a 3x Pro Bowler and a decade-long 1,000-yard threat — the realistic outcome.

/ Ceiling
Marvin HarrisonIND

Slender, technique-first outside WR who becomes a first-ballot Hall of Famer through elite routes, hands, and QB pairing — Smith's absolute ceiling.

/ Floor
Marquise BrownBAL/ARI/KC

Small-frame WR whose game translates but whose durability limits him to injury-shortened seasons — the frame-driven downside.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
4
Career AV
42

2021 (PHI, rookie): 64-916-5 in 17 games. Rookie franchise record for receiving yards. Became Jalen Hurts's primary target and helped Philadelphia return to the playoffs. PFWA All-Rookie honorable mention. 2022 (PHI): 95-1,196-7 in 17 games. Second WR to hit 1,000 yards in an offensive scheme that reached Super Bowl LVII. Elite chemistry with Hurts — third-down and red-zone go-to receiver despite A.J. Brown's arrival. 2023 (PHI): 81-1,066-7 in 17 games. Third-team All-Pro, first Pro Bowl selection. Continued to operate as the perfect complement to A.J. Brown — the Eagles' WR duo combined for 2,522 yards. Signed a 3-year, $75M extension in April 2024. 2024 (PHI): 68-833-8 in 17 games. Super Bowl LIX champion — 4 catches for 69 yards and a critical TD vs Kansas City. Continued the Brown/Smith duo dominance. 2025 (PHI): Playing under the new extension as the Eagles' co-WR1 alongside A.J. Brown. Career track: Super Bowl champion, 1x Pro Bowl, 1x All-Pro, four 800+ yard seasons out of first four, and the durability concern that scared teams pre-draft never materialized — a legitimate hit at #10.

DeVonta Smith is the first wide receiver to win the Heisman since 1991 and enters the NFL with a résumé that looks like it belongs to a first overall pick — 117 receptions, 1,856 yards, and 23 touchdowns in 13 games, an FBS record for touchdowns in a season, plus the Biletnikoff, Maxwell, Walter Camp, and consensus AP Player of the Year. The tape matches the résumé: he is the best route runner in the class and among the best college WR route runners of the last decade.

The technical foundation is extraordinary. Smith sells vertical stems with head-and-shoulder detail that most veterans never develop, sinks his hips at the top of comebacks and digs with a suddenness that creates late separation, and reads coverage rotation post-snap to adjust stem angles into open grass. Route IQ is Marvin Harrison-adjacent — he understands leverage, plays with a purpose on every step, and never wastes movement. The hands are the second layer of the profile: 3 drops on 240 career targets (1.25% drop rate), catches away from his frame, and a 63% contested-catch rate despite giving up 40+ pounds and 3+ inches to defenders on those reps.

The evaluation debate is entirely about the frame. Smith is 6'0", 170 lbs — measured 166 at his pro day — the lightest first-round WR of the modern era. Physical NFL corners with active hands will disrupt his release more often than college corners did, and the JuJu Smith-Schuster-style physical route running is not on his menu. The functional strength question extends to blocking (willing but overmatched) and durability (the biggest question for any 170-pound WR taken top-10). YAC will always be scheme-dependent rather than tackle-breaking; he creates YAC in space, not through contact.

The counter to the frame concern is what's on tape: he does not drop the ball, he does not lose 50/50 reps against bigger DBs, and he has three seasons of dominant SEC production against every top corner in the class (including Patrick Surtain II in practice every day). His 32.5" arms are longer than the average WR his size, and his release package neutralizes press because he wins with hand-fighting technique, not brute strength.

For Philadelphia at #10 (traded up one spot from #12 to jump the Giants), the fit is a Jalen Hurts-led scheme reunion. Smith and Hurts played together at Alabama; the anticipation timing and route detail translate immediately. The Eagles get their long-term WR1 in the same draft they're trying to unlock the Hurts era.

The floor is Marquise Brown — a small-frame WR whose game translates but whose durability caps him at injury-shortened seasons. The realistic median is DeSean Jackson: an undersized but technically brilliant WR who becomes a 3x Pro Bowler and a decade-long 1,000-yard threat. The ceiling — the reason he goes top 10 despite 166 lbs on the scale — is Marvin Harrison: a slender, technique-first outside WR whose elite routes, hands, and QB pairing turn him into a first-ballot Hall of Famer.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile