Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021R6 · #212
S· Round 6

Damar
Hamlin.

Damar Hamlin
Sickos Grade
47.3/100

Pittsburgh official athletic logoPittsburgh· 6'0"· 200 lb· 4.60s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9327
National · #152HS class · 2016
Central Catholic, PA
247Sports composite via CFBD
R6 · #212 · BUF

"A 6'0", 200-pound five-year Pitt safety with a 4.60 forty, 35" vert and 48 career starts split across free and box — a Day 3 rotational safety and core special-teams bet where instincts and toughness had to survive middling long speed."Pre-draft read

01Play style

This multiple safety plays most comfortably as a post or robber in split and single-high safety looks. He diagnoses run and pass quickly, triggers downhill with clean angles, and finishes as a wrap tackler who secures the ball-carrier's legs. He rarely opens the gate and plays with disciplined eyes.

His man coverage against tight ends and backs is functional. In zone coverage, he communicates rotations, passes off crossers cleanly, and shows late-hands range on throws he can drive on. On special teams, he is a plus player, demonstrating gunner speed, willing wedge-busting on kickoff coverage, and reliable play on both punt teams.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

The ideal habitat for Damar Hamlin is a two-high safety system like the Fangio or Cover-2 principles, where his processing and communication skills are prioritized.

Free safety (two-high)Box safety (dime)Special teams gunnerMiddile-of-field robber
Best role

Initially, a core special-teamer and dime safety, eventually growing into a permanent fixture as a starting free or strong safety in a two-high look.

Wrong fit

A single-high Cover-1 scheme where his adequate long speed would be an immediate liability.

Hamlin’s football IQ and versatility make him a high-floor rotational piece and special teams ace, best utilized in schemes that emphasize disciplined play over raw athleticism.

03Film room

Damar Hamlin 2020 Regular Season Highlights | Pittsburgh DB

Full senior-season tape at Pitt showing coverage snaps, tackling in the fit and multi-alignment usage under Narduzzi.

Pitt Safety Damar Hamlin Official Senior Year Highlights

Official Pitt cut of his senior year — the exact tape most NFL rooms watched pre-draft.

Damar Hamlin snags first career INT from Trevor Lawrence

Rookie-year Bills clip: first career interception, reading the deep middle against Jacksonville.

04The evaluation

This player projects as a high-floor rotational safety and core special-teamer, offering immediate value due to his versatility and football IQ. A team acquires a defender capable of playing consistently across multiple alignments in the secondary and on special teams, making him a reliable depth piece who can fill various roles as needed.

As a five-year starter at Pittsburgh, he accumulated 48 starts, playing free safety, box safety, slot, and dime linebacker. This extensive experience provided a broad understanding of defensive schemes and responsibilities. He was deployed as a green-dot communicator and amassed 285 tackles and six interceptions, showcasing consistent production at a high-competition level.

Evaluators consistently placed him firmly on Day 3 of the draft, primarily in the sixth-to-seventh-round range, recognizing his solid but not explosive athletic profile. Concerns centered on his average long speed for free safety archetypes and a lack of a clear "spike" in interception production. Drafted by Buffalo with the 212th pick, he was valued as a high-character, versatile player with immediate special teams impact.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Versatility across the back end

    Started at both safeties, slot, and dime linebacker at Pitt; trusted as a green-dot communicator. NFL coaches see a legitimate three-position piece.

  2. 02

    Football IQ and processing

    Reads three-step concepts quickly and drives on curls and hooks with anticipation. Rarely misfits run/pass keys.

  3. 03

    Tackling in the fit

    Career 285 tackles; attacks downhill with balanced pad level, wraps as a form tackler, and finishes with reliable contact.

  4. 04

    Special teams profile

    Above-average gunner speed for a safety, physical wedge-buster on kickoff coverage, and enough short-area quickness for punt-team vise.

  5. 05

    Ball skills for a safety of his profile

    Six career picks and a stack of pass breakups. Ball tracking on deep-middle throws is clean; finishes with two hands.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Long speed is average

    4.60 forty time and 4.40 shuttle put him a half-tick behind top NFL free-safety archetypes, relying on eyes and angles.

  2. 02

    Man coverage vs. NFL slot receivers

    Struggles to mirror twitchier slot types on option routes; hips are willing but not elite, needing safety-over help.

  3. 03

    Frame and play strength are average

    200 pounds with a modest bench (18 reps) and slender build, wins with technique rather than displacement.

  4. 04

    Age and developmental ceiling

    A 23-year-old fifth-year senior with well-defined traits, suggesting limited further growth in his athletic ceiling.

07Athletic testing
Height
6'0"
Weight
200 lb
40 yd
4.60s
Vertical
35"
Broad
9'10"
3-cone
6.93s
Shuttle
4.40s
Bench
18
Relative Athletic Score
6.81
/10 · official

Relative Athletic Score (Kent Lee Platte) benchmarks combine/pro-day numbers against every measured prospect at the position since 1987. 10.00 is elite; 5.00 is average.

06Athletic profilevs. S on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.60sp50
Vertical
35inp50
Broad jump
118inp50
Three-cone
6.93sp50
Shuttle
4.40sp50
Bench
18repp50
08College production
YrTeamGTklSkIntPDFF
2016Pittsburgh380000
2017Pittsburgh9410100
2018Pittsburgh13850240
2019Pittsburgh138401100
2020Pittsburgh10660270
Career4828406210

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Jaquiski TarttSF

Realistic outcome: multi-safety role player who alternates between rotational starter and top-of-depth-chart backup depending on health, with real special-teams value baked in every year.

/ Ceiling
Jordan PoyerBUF

Best-case fit: undersized ACC/Big-12 safety who processed his way into a starter role in a McDermott/Frazier two-high scheme. The mental profile matches; the takeaway spike is the extra step Hamlin never quite hit at Pitt.

/ Floor
Doug MiddletonJAX

Downside: career backup safety and core special-teamer whose defensive snaps are entirely injury-driven. That was the pre-draft floor for a sixth-round safety without elite testing.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV

Pre-draft context. Hamlin arrived at Pittsburgh in 2016 as a four-star local product out of Central Catholic and ended up starting 48 games across five seasons, sliding between free safety, box and slot as the team's needs dictated. He never posted the interception spike desired from a top-100 safety — six career picks with a career-best 67 tackles in 2018 — but the Panthers played him in every possible alignment and used him as a green-dot communicator. He tested cleanly at Pitt's pro day (6'0"/200, 4.60, 35" vertical, 118" broad, 6.93 three-cone, 4.40 shuttle, RAS 6.81), a solid but not explosive workout that matched his tape: capable in coverage, willing in the run fit, without the fifth gear to erase mistakes at the third level. Boards had him in a wide sixth-to-seventh-round range as a special-teams-first depth safety with legitimate football character.

NFL fit — Buffalo Bills. Buffalo traded up from Houston to take Hamlin at 212, a profile that aligned with the team's approach: multiple safety, high floor, plus special teams, ready-made deep-third and hook defender. Reunited with fellow Pitt alum Dane Jackson, he immediately locked down phase-four snaps as a rookie, played 68 percent of special-teams snaps as a first-year Bill, and by 2022 had grown into the starting free-safety job when Micah Hyde went down. The scheme fit was clean — post safety in single-high, robber in Cover-2, occasional slot rotation — and Hamlin was one of the surprise ascending role players of that Bills defense.

Retrospective. Hamlin suffered cardiac arrest on the field in Cincinnati on January 2, 2023, an event that briefly stopped the season and reframed how his career is discussed. He returned to the active roster in 2023, moved back into the rotation, and by 2024–25 was again logging real defensive snaps for Buffalo alongside his special-teams role. Draft-value math is unambiguous: a sixth-round safety who became a starting-caliber contributor and long-tenured Bill is a firm hit on the pick. Everything after that belongs to a different scouting document.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile