Skip to content
Draft Sickos
Back to the 2021 class
Retrospective scouting report · Class of 2021Consensus #085
WR· Round 3

Amari
Rodgers.

Amari Rodgers
Sickos Grade
62.9/100
Pre-draft #85

Clemson official athletic logoClemson· 5'9"· 212 lb· 4.52s 40

/ Recruiting profile
★★★★stars.9453
National · #117HS class · 2017
Knoxville Catholic, TN
247Sports composite via CFBD
R3 · #85 · Green Bay Packers

"A Clemson slot with plus quickness and career-long production but a 5'9", 212-lb frame that projected as a manufactured-touch WR3 at the pro level."Pre-draft read

01Play style

He aligns almost exclusively in the slot, with heavy usage on jet sweeps, screens, drags, and shallow crossers as a manufactured-touch element. His primary win trait is short-area quickness, paired with above-average contact balance due to a thick lower half. He consistently drives through arm tackles and makes the first defender miss on bubble screens. The shallow route tree focuses on option routes, slants, digs, and jet motion.

His functional hands exhibit a tendency to body-catch targets outside his frame, particularly on 15-plus yard throws. He is not a vertical threat nor a contested-catch winner, lacking the length or leaping ability necessary to high-point balls. Separation on routes is often achieved through motion, rather than nuanced release techniques.

02Scheme fit
Ideal system

The ideal fit is a West Coast timing or spread RPO offense that emphasizes quick hitters, designed touches, and manufactured separation for its slot receivers.

Slot WRKick ReturnerPunt ReturnerMotion/Jet SweepBubble Screen Threat
Best role

He projects as a Year 1 contributor in a designated slot role, primarily as a short-area chain-mover and return specialist, with a ceiling as a reliable, high-volume slot receiver in a rhythm passing game.

Wrong fit

He would struggle significantly in a vertical Air Raid or play-action heavy offense that relies on outside receivers winning contested catches downfield.

Rodgers thrives in schemes that prioritize short-area quickness and tackle-breaking after the catch, but his limited route tree and lack of vertical juice cap his potential in more diverse passing attacks.

03Film room

Amari Rodgers 2020 Regular Season Highlights | Clemson WR

Senior-year Clemson reel — 77-1,020-7 season, slot usage, jet sweeps, shallow crossers.

Clemson WR Amari Rodgers Highlights

Career highlight reel — contact balance and short-area quickness on manufactured touches.

Amari Rodgers Clemson | Life and Football

Pre-draft scouting-style feature with route/route-tree breakdown and ACL rehab context.

04The evaluation

As a four-year Clemson slot receiver, Rodgers projects as a legitimate slot separator in the 5-to-15-yard range. His compact, dense frame and solid 6.94 three-cone time confirm his short-area quickness, underscoring his ability to create separation. Teams are acquiring a player with plus-strength for his size and a background as a punt returner, providing an immediate special teams floor and a high-floor locker room fit.

His senior season, where he recorded 77 receptions for 1,020 yards and seven touchdowns, primarily involved screens, jet motion, and short in-breakers. Clemson heavily utilized him for designed touches, a role he consistently produced in. His early 2018 ACL injury was fully resolved by his 2019 season, removing medical concerns, and his coach's-son background contributed to a high-character profile that scouts valued.

Evaluators noted concerns about his body-catching tendency on contested targets, minimal vertical ability, and a limited route tree that rarely extended beyond manufactured plays. Despite these flags, consensus positioned him as a late-second to early-third-round prospect. He was ultimately drafted in the third round, 85th overall, by Green Bay, representing their first top-100 receiver investment since 2014.

05Strengths
  1. 01

    Contact balance for size

    thick lower half allows him to drive through arm tackles on screens and jet sweeps, evidenced by consistent tackle-breaking after short catches.

  2. 02

    Short-area quickness

    a 6.94 three-cone time at 212 pounds confirms legitimate slot quickness, enabling clean separation on option routes and shallow crossers against nickel defenders.

  3. 03

    Manufactured-touch weapon

    consistent positive plays on jet sweeps, tunnel screens, and bubble motions, demonstrating immediate value in a designed-touch role at the NFL level.

  4. 04

    Coach's son intangibles

    solid character, four-year starter, and team captain as a senior, signaling a plug-and-play locker-room fit for a veteran environment.

  5. 05

    Return background

    three years of punt-return reps and production provide a Day-3 special-teams floor, enhancing his value even in a limited receiver outcome.

06Concerns
  1. 01

    Contested-catch profile

    short frame, 9 3/8-inch hands, and average leaping mean he does not win above 6 feet; college tape showed a body-catching tendency on outside targets.

  2. 02

    Route tree cap

    college route tree heavily featured screens, jets, drags, and slants; rarely worked vertically or ran true intermediate routes against man coverage, limiting his projected role.

  3. 03

    Vertical juice

    4.52 pro-day forty is functional but not a separator, with no discernible extra gears past 20 yards, capping his ceiling as a deep threat.

  4. 04

    Level of manufactured usage

    a large portion of college production came from plays akin to handoffs, making it difficult to separate receiver skill from scheme.

07Athletic testing
Height
5'9"
Weight
212 lb
40 yd
4.52s
Vertical
33"
Broad
10'1"
3-cone
7.07s
Shuttle
4.31s
Bench
19
06Athletic profilevs. WR on Big Board
40VERTBRD3CSHTLBNCH

— — — positional median (p50)

40 yd
4.52sp50
Vertical
33inp50
Broad jump
121inp50
Three-cone
7.07sp50
Shuttle
4.31sp50
Bench
19repp50
08College production
YrTeamGRecYdsTD
2017Clemson14191230
2018Clemson15555754
2019Clemson14304264
2020Clemson127710207
Career55181214415

A dash means the figure is not published by a source we trust — never a zero we invented.

/ Usage share, 2020
11.0%of team plays
89 percentile at positionClemson
Pass plays · 19.5%Run plays · 0.3%Third down · 10.1%Passing downs · 11.3%
CFBD usage — share of the offense's plays involving the player
09Pro comparisons
/ Likely outcome
Trent TaylorSF

Under-6-foot manufactured-touch slot who carved out a rotational role with return value but never became a full-menu route runner — closest realistic outcome given the same tree limits.

/ Ceiling
Randall CobbGB

Green Bay literally drafted him to be the next Cobb — compact, tough, coach-friendly slot with return juice; this is the ceiling case where he becomes a 60-catch, chain-moving WR3 with punt value.

/ Floor
Ryan SwitzerDAL

Slot-and-returner Day-2 pick whose hands under contested conditions and return security both cratered in the NFL, forcing a fast release from the drafting team — this is the outcome that actually landed.

10In hindsight

Everything above is the pre-draft evaluation. This section is what actually happened — updated year over year.

Pro Bowls
0
All-Pro
0
Seasons
Career AV
1

Bust. 8 catches as a rookie, muffed a critical punt in the NFC Championship. Cut before Year 3, signed with Houston as depth in 2023, out of the league by 2025. Frame and separation limits caught up.

**Pre-draft context.** Amari Rodgers arrived in Clemson as the son of former Tennessee national champion QB and longtime college assistant Tee Martin, and left as a four-year contributor who capped his career with a first-team All-ACC senior season: 77 catches for 1,020 yards and seven touchdowns in 2020, with a 13.2 yards-per-reception mark that quieted early "just a screen-and-slant guy" concerns. He tore his ACL in the spring of 2018, returned to play as a true junior, and by his final year was Trevor Lawrence's security blanket underneath, on jet sweeps and as the primary punt returner. He measured 5'9 5/8"/212 with 9 3/8" hands at his pro day and ran a reported 4.52 forty at 212 pounds — legitimate slot testing numbers on a compact, dense frame. Board consensus landed him in the late-second-to-early-third range as a plug-and-play slot with return value; the Packers took him at 85 as the first receiver they had drafted in the first three rounds since Davante Adams in 2014, in a class where the top-of-round WRs (Chase, Waddle, Smith, Bateman, Toney) had all come off the board.

**NFL fit — Green Bay.** Green Bay bet on Rodgers as a Randall Cobb replacement in the slot and as the punt returner Tyler Ervin had failed to lock down. It never fit. Rushed onto special teams as a rookie, he muffed multiple punts, was benched on returns, and finished his first year with just four catches for 45 yards while Cobb was actually re-acquired mid-season. His second training camp produced flashes but the season collapsed the same way: he was inactive for stretches, muffed another punt in the London loss to the Giants, and was released after just three games in October 2022 with six career receptions. He bounced to the Texans practice squad, then the Buffalo Bills active roster for a stretch in 2023, then the Ravens and the UFL's Birmingham Stallions in 2024, where he actually produced as a slot in the spring league.

**Retrospective.** Rodgers is a clean case study in how "safe slot with return upside" can still miss on both fronts if hands under contested conditions never arrive. The pre-draft evaluation was largely accurate on the tools — compact, strong, reliable on manufactured touches — and largely accurate on the ceiling cap (no vertical juice, limited catch radius). What the board missed, or under-weighted, was how brittle his hands got when the ball wasn't schemed to him: drop rate spiked on contested targets in Green Bay, and the punt-return job never stabilized because he lacked the tracking reps and confidence at the position. In a class defined by top-tier WR talent going in the first round, a Day-2 slot who never carved out a rotational role sits closer to bust than backup, and Green Bay used a comp pick two years later to draft his eventual replacement in Jayden Reed.

Draft Sickos · retrospective scouting profile